I do think more people learning to sing, play instruments, etc. would be beneficial. In the 19th century there was something called parlor music, where before recorded music became popular, they would get songbooks and sing and play from them if they wanted to hear a song less expensively. Not that that is the solution but it shows how people did it before
Learning to sing/play music is healthy for the brain too!
Modern society seems to push people into ever more specialization. I don’t think this is good for us, we are meant to be well rounded human beings! Maybe we don’t need to do everything but the one pointed focus is bad for making connections between things (e.g. in science and other realms) and reflects the assembly line model of society.
There is a local old-time duo I saw the other day that is good but doesn’t have anything at all that’s recorded—the only way you would hear them is by going out and hearing them! In this case they had a tip jar that was well announced (though that doesn’t feel like the best solution to me, however it was not an ordinary place).
And a musician I know, left three songs out of the online versions of his album (and in my opinion they were some of the best of the songs), because they couldn’t guarantee that the songs were in the right order, so they can only be heard on CD or vinyl—in the right order.
I play and sing and write songs, and am moderately good at it, but don’t ever want to “be a musician” of the sort who tours around, publishes things, etc. It seems stressful and I want to focus on things like picking mushrooms and acorns in the woods!
The other night while I was sorting and cracking acorns I started singing spontaneously, a little acorn song of sorts. I didn’t write it out beforehand, just sang something that seemed fitting. In previous times this was so common. Masanobu Fukuoka wrote something along the lines of “gone now is the sound of the woodcutter’s song”—maybe, we can sing it again?
Oops, rambled off topic— as can be told from the story of the person who left three of the best songs out of streaming, it seems like musicians could just refuse to put their music out that way and some have. I think an equally salient question is, despite streaming not being very helpful to musicians, how can listeners (by any means) do their best to support the musicians they listen to?