And now about the mistakes that in retrospect I realised we made:
- we could have made the pond twice as big (=longer pond) - the amount of water through the French drain and the gutters would have been more than
enough !!
- I said earlier that the operator was okay at following instructions - yes, just okay, not great; despite my repeated insistence on a milder slope for the sides of the pond, we still ended up with sides that are a bit too steep
- because of the steep sides, we did a less than perfect job at compacting them - we had to rely on the light-weight excavator alone as the roller couldn't get onto the steep sides
- I underestimated the extent of settling of the dam. Six months after we built the pond, the dam settled about 20 centimetres below its original height. I don't think this was because of insufficient compaction - we were very thorough in compacting the dam as we built it (the roller went over it a dozen times for every 25-30 cm of earth that was added). As a consequence of settling, the dam is now 20 cm below the level of the back of the pond. This is slightly disturbing visually (back of the pond higher than the front). I will have to remedy this by adding a few inches of clay on top of the dam - I will do this with a wheelbarrow and shovel (I've already set aside some earth obtained from another excavation).
... So that's it for now.
Comments, critique, and suggestions will be appreciated !