Bill Norton

Hello there!

It's been a little while since I checked in. I wanted to make sure I had some success to report. I now have not only leveled with my whole family, but I have emailed all 50 states about what I am up to. Of the 15 states that have responded so far, Kansas has the most progressive stance. They are the only one to allow third party transportation of toilet material at the state level (local county ordinances can still prohibit it). Is anybody in this audience from Kansas? I'm really optimistic about that state, not only because of its policies, but because Katie Basiotis from there is very helpful, and seems to be behind the concept.

I'm really surprised I haven't heard yet from California, Oregon, Colorado, or Pennsylvania. I would think they'd be all over it. Well, we'll see. It is the Holidays, after all. One thing I am strongly considering is a booth at the Minnesota State Fair next summer, preferably within the Eco Experience building. It's a little over a grand for the 12-day event, but the exposure might prove invaluable.

Here's my take on the topic: I think the state Pollution Control Agencies secretly understand, or at least sense, the wisdom of humanure composting. Otherwise why would so many backyard composters be allowed to operate under the radar? One writer to Joe from Texas stated that the TPCA insisted that if he were going to recycle humanure, he had to use this official, expensive, composting toilet. Finally he relented and bought the damn thing--all $1300 worth, then proceeded to never use it. He never heard from the TPCA again. I really don't think their hearts are into making criminals out of composters. It's just that they have stuck-in-the-box thinking, and whenever one of these composting operations gets a little bit permies, they feel they have to "do something" to maintain the status quo.

All of this would be tolerable except for two things: 1) Getting the word out is next to impossible, or at best a daunting task. I'll bet about 80% of the population doesn't even know that humanure composting is a thing. 2) Since renters and condominium owners don't own any land, they can't compost even if they want to, and no business enabling them to would be allowed to operate. Even a business that exclusively catered to homeowners who own their own land and would gladly pay to have someone set up and maintain their composting system would still be above the radar and probably be forced to shut down.

The problem is mindset--starting with my own. I need to have many uncomfortable conversations with environmentalist groups and/or churches where my idea might gain some traction, but I haven't even completely leveled with my  own family about what I am up to. Not exactly courageous of me. My oldest son caught me once in an unguarded moment when I spilled it all. He was a little skeptical that it could succeed, but that's about it. I don't know what I am so afraid of!

Regarding my letter to the MPCA, talk about your typical non-answer. Get a load of this;

Hi Bill,



Cody is out of the office for a while, so he asked me to get back to you to clarify a few things.  First per definition the human waste is considered sewage and would need to be treated and disposed of per Minnesota rule.

7080.1100 Subp. 73. Sewage. “Sewage” means waste produced by toilets, bathing, laundry, or culinary operations or the floor drains associated with these sources, and includes household cleaners, medications, and other constituents in sewage restricted to amounts normally used for domestic purposes.



To answer your question about the humanure site.  The process will not meet the performance outcomes as required for the treatment and disposal of sewage in Minnesota, and will not meet the rules’ intent for the protection of public health and the environment. Cody’s email below outlines the rules and performance outcomes.



Thanks for the inquiry and let me know if there is anything else I can be of assistance with. Unfortunately Humanure composting would not be allowed in Minnesota under Subsurface Sewage Treatment System rules.





Steven Oscarson

Environmental Specialist

Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

In other words, feces and urine are automatically sewage waste, regardless of how they are handled (not exactly out-of-the-box thinking). Notice he never specifically stated what health hazard the humanure site posed. He merely restated that it didn't meet intended "outcomes." Finally, my sustainability concern was ignored. As far as public health is concerned, according to the Humanure Handbook, there are some pathogens (E-coli I believe is one of them) that are resistant to water treatments, but that are destroyed by thermophilic composting.

John: Love it! Especially the theme song at the end.

I had a brainstorm superhero scenario in my head that I just HAD to write down. I'll share it now for anyone interested. Feel free to embellish if you like:

Heroes And Villains

Heroes: Mother Nurture--the main hero. Her main powers are the creation and
maintenence of the Book of Knowledge, which, once accessed
through any medium, provides a path to the Realm of Quiet,
the place where all wisdom lies. This Realm is the one place
Ick cannot penetrate.
Info*--Nurture's chief assistant. His job is to "spread the word" about
the existence of the Realm of Quiet and the secrets that lie
within it. The main power of these secrets is that they absolutely
cannot be used nefariously. The trick is they are unattainable
through any act of will, making it very easy for Madam Ick and
Borometer to lure people away with seductive powers.
Covera--She can shoot natural cover material at Ick, neutralizing her
stench. The problem is that time is usually not on Covera's side.
Unless she can work quickly and completely, most people will act
rashly and use the flusher that Fecoramus provided them to flush
away Ick, not realizing that every time they flush, they are
actually increasing the size of Ick's Pool of Stench.

*lame name. gotta work on that one.

Villains: Madam Ick--the head villain. Her main powers are her incredible stench
to drive people away from things that threaten her (especially the
Realm of Quiet) and her ability to create distracting noises to
keep people busy and to drown out any wisdom. She is so adept at
touching off fear and anger that even the combined sage advice of
Info and Covera is usually no match for her. Only the most
determined and humble can see past Ick's odorous ruse.
         Borometer--Ick's chief assistant. His job is to maintain an impenetrable
wall of boredom around the Realm of Quiet. This is not as easy as
it sounds, because not having anything to do might actually
ATTRACT a fair number of people who are fed up with the
"Rat Race." For these people, he must trick them into circular
thinking that creates a false sense of urgency, then exploit their
sense of guilt to steer them away from the Realm of Quiet.
 Fecoramus--Feco is a clueless Innocent, often manipulated into doing
Urban Legendo's deceptive dirty work.
 Alwaysdunnitar--Good with camera angles, and well aware of the hypnotic
power of the status quo, Dunnitar's specialty is to present the
grinding status quo from an overhead angle to make it appear to be
a circle of sustainability, disguising the fact that below the
pleasing circular head is a grooved screw that grinds away
destructively with each revolution.
 Urban Legendo--As the name implies, Urban's main talent is deception.
With the catalyzing assistance of the unwitting sidekick
Fecoramus, Urban can spread disinformation with lightning speed.



I have left pronouns out of Fecoramus's, Alwaysdunnitar's, and Urban Legendo's
descriptions on purpose. I have not decided on a gender for any of them.

The following is an email I sent to Cody Robinson from MPCA, who was kind enough to take the time to respond to my idea:

Hello Cody,

Thank you for taking the time to respond to my inquiry. I hope you had a happy and restful Thanksgiving. B and C in section 2150 refer to effluent, which is irrelevant to the project, as composting produces no sewage and therefore no effluent to manage. D is indeed very important and is addressed in the Humanure Handbook, although specific measurements aren't given. I'm guessing that how much bedding is needed to ensure no seepage into the groundwater will vary depending on local soil conditions. 2,3, and 5 of section 1500 deal with proper cover of fecal material, and this is where composting really shines, because since it is handled above ground, the nose is the perfect guide. If it stinks, it is not adequately covered. Once it is adequately covered, pets and vermin have no interest in it. Then thermophilic bacteria heat up the pile enough to kill the majority of pathogens, with proper aging (about a year) taking care of the rest. In fact, most pathogens cannot exist more than a few weeks to a month outside the human host. Section 1500, #4, revisits the contamination issue I already addressed above for 2150D. Section 2150A and section 1500, #1 deal with procedural issues (licensing, etc) and are not a real concern of mine other than my desire not to criminalize people who want to participate in this project. The "ick" factor alone will prevent 99% of the population from even considering participation. Humanure composting, however, is sustainable for every human being on the planet until the end of time. On the other hand, if the sewer system were adopted by every human being on the planet, the world's freshwater supply would dry up on day one. I'm convinced that once the other 99% see this process successfully executed, they will slowly cross over, maybe even in my lifetime (although I'm 60, so I'm not betting the farm on that one!).

Incidentally, I'm curious what the MPCA thought was unsafe about the Minnesota resident's humanure composting pile. I'm sure it's not anything that couldn't be easily addressed.

-Bill

p.s. Composting can even remediate soil already contaminated, such as at spent munitions plants.

We'll see what happens now. Jenny: Thank for the suggestion of offering the on-site service to interested homeowners. Soon I will make a video and link to it in my LinkedIn page.

Pearl wrote:

" There was links on one of them (I forget which) that talked of some current night soil systems, where people are using the best of history and modern tech. Those may have some good ideas for you." I'll check those out, Pearl. Thank you.

Anne: As promised, I followed through on Debbie Thao's suggestion. Here is what I sent to Timothy Farnan at the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's solid waste department:

Hello Timothy,

I'm interested in starting a humanure composting service. Besides being unsustainable, the current sewer system erroneously takes for granted that feces and urine are waste materials. When properly composted (adequately covered and aged about a year), they can actually be resources. Humanure composting is described in detail in The Humanure Handbook, by Joseph Jenkins.

I realize this is a new concept in the United States (the MPCA site does not even mention it). Perhaps it could start as a small, closely monitored pilot project. If approved, I would consult with Mr. Jenkins and other experts to make sure it got done right. I would be more than delighted to do the "dirty work," so to speak.

Why I think this service is so important is that although many homeowners already do this, a good third of the population rents, and many owners are condominium dwellers who only own their units, not any of the land they reside on, so none of these people (myself included because I rent) can participate even if they want to.

Please get back to me as soon as you can. Thank you,

-Bill


We'll see what happens from here.

Kenneth,

Actually I already contacted somebody at the MS Society regarding the possibility of setting up some composting port-a-potties. I haven't heard back yet. It could start on a small scale as one or two units at a few scattered stops along the MS150 bike route. If approved, though, I would still have the challenge of finding a piece of land to compost on, unless someone were willing to donate a small portion of their land for the cause. On a small scale, that wouldn't be a problem, but I'm sure larger scale operations would probably require special zoning and permitting.

Anne,

Debbie got back to me and suggested I contact the MN Pollution Control Agency. I'll get to that in the next few days (hold my feet to the fire on that, because I tend to procrastinate!)

Pearl,

I managed to get through half the video, and I will check out the links, but I'm a little skeptical about how applicable these foreign operations will be to the possibility of setting something up here. Joseph Jenkins pointed out that some of those "night soil" operations had health concerns, as well as being "an assault on the senses," so I am a little gun shy about using those as models for a U.S. operation.

Anne,

Good point. I sent the following reply. We'll see what happens from there:

Hello Debbie,

Just making sure, "humanure" refers to human feces and urine. When you referred to "Mortuary Science," I got a little nervous, thinking that maybe you were confusing it with "green burial," which is something I would be interested in exploring for myself when my time comes, but that is not what I am referring to here. The humanure concept is described in great detail in "The Humanure Handbook," by Joseph Jenkins.

The following is a reply I got this morning from the Minnesota Department of Health:

Dear Mr. Bill Norton,



I am in receipt of the email inquiry you submitted regarding interest in starting a humanure composting service.  I will consult with the Mortuary Science section team and either myself or a team member will get back to you.  Thank you.



An email was sent by:

Name:  Bill Norton
Email:  humanurenow@gmail.com
URL of website:  
Comments:  I want to start a humanure composting service. Humanure composting is
already happening in private back yards, but the mission of this business is to
bring that capability to everyone who wants it, regardless of where they live. If
done properly (proper covering and aging for about a year), composting
completely destroys pathogens, and without the use of dangerous chemicals. I
would need a small plot of land, though, and with potentially hundreds or
even thousands of customers, I'm guessing special permitting and zoning
would be required.


I'm not quite sure what the Mortuary Science team would have to do with this, but at least it wasn't a flat out denial. We'll see...