The 3 Core Ethics
Every permaculture decision is guided by three foundational ethics:
• Earth Care: Rebuilding and maintaining natural systems so life can persist.
• People Care: Supporting self-reliance, community well-being, and basic human needs.
• Fair Share: Limiting consumption, redistributing surplus, and living within planetary limits.
I think this discussion is around the tension between People Care and Earth Care.
We can all see the value in reducing waste, but the impact of that on people is harder to pin down.
"People Care" should include all the complex implications around mental and physical health. When reducing waste - for example by collecting "just in case" items - starts to impact quality of life then we should take those considerations seriously.
Recently at home I put my foot down about our laundry situation. We now have a tumble drier for the first time in our married lives and it is wonderful. We live in the UK and our autumn and winters are damp, with things drying slowly. We've spent years surrounded in our living spaces by damp clothes draped over every possible point, such that our living room didn't feel restful to use. Moving through the kitchen involved lifting drying racks out of the way to get to cupboards, and the slow drying process inevitably ended up with having to deal with giant piles of cleaned and (eventually!) dry washing to sort all at once.
When the weather is fine we still use our outdoor clothes line.
When the weather is not suitable we can use the tumble drier.
"Earth Care" is factored in because we now have an electric car and cheap electricity rate that cuts in when the balance of renewable electricity on our grid drops the electricity price low. Essentially when we do choose to run the drier (overnight in off peak hours) we are not adding to fossil fuel use.
Bottom line - people matter, we should be comfortable making choices that prioritise people over "stuff". There is tension between the permaculture ethics, but that is not a reason to discard the needs of people to live in environments that meet their needs.