Buff and pilgrim have good reputations. My embdens and African female were good. I hand raised them so they imprinted on me as their mother. They hated everyone else though. But much depends on strain and luck of the draw. As I said pilgrim and buff are probably best overall, but can be expensive and hard to find
When you reach your lowest point, you are open to the greatest change.
I chose czech goose ("husa česká"), our saved national breed. Some 150 years ago very common in every czech village, nowadays only several hundreds birds.. This breed is very resilient, it endures winter freeze outdoors, females are excelent mothers, they lay some 10-12 eggs in February, sit on them patiently, whilst male keep guard. They take care of goslings very well. You don´t have to feed them with "industrial mix" , just green pasture for adults, some crushed grain with buttermilk and boiled eggs with green for young. Excelent grazers. I use them in my vineyard. Great guard birds. These mine are quite aggresive against people, especially now, when they have goslings.