Broadforks

The opinions on broadforks seem to be very divided, some people use them as an essential part of their gardening, others say they are overrated.

I think these opinions have a lot to do with the soil they're working with, and if there are any back problems to consider. I imagine that very stony soil would be tricky to use a broadfork with. For people who can use normal short-handled tools without back damage, they probably can't imagine just how good it is for someone that can't use normal forks to have a tool they can use without pain.

I like mine a lot. I chose a very strong one which looks similar to the Meadow Creature but is made closer to where I live. One day, I might get a 7 tine one for quickly working established beds, but for now I am working with compacted soil, and a smaller 5 tine broadfork is great for that.

I use mine for opening up my heavy and compacted soil to help roots go down, for loosening soil before digging a hole, and I can use it as a small-scale chisel plough to improve pasture and perennial plantings. It is an essential part of the way I homestead on this land.

What are your thoughts on broadforks? Do you use one? What do you use it for?

I love mine.  Lately I have been using it to aerate my dad's lawn.

we use ours for, digging in general, we dig our root vegetables with them. We have 3 tine forks and some 5 tine forks. The 3 we use mostly in the garden to either turn soil over or to dig root vegetables out. The 5 tine one we use mostly for turning compost, cleaning the goat pens, shovelling sawdust/woodchips.


I would use a normal shovel for digging a hole for a tree, or to excavate a drain. somewhere where i need to move soil out of the spot i am digging in.

I don't have one personally, like scythe it is just for folks with different soil and terrain.

However I love the idea. Both broadfork and scythe and great tools for the area they are usefully in.

I've had one for a couple of years and my experience has been mixed. It's been great for renovating existing beds that I haven't dug since forming them (and don't want to dig again, because I'm a no-dig kind of guy). But our land is rocky, a former river channel, with varying sizes of stones from gravel to 30 cm boulders at a range of depths from the surface to over 1m down. If one of the tines hits a decent-sized rock, it usually bends, and even if it doesn't it means that section won't get broken up effectively. I might weld some gusset plates into the curved part of the tines to stiffen them and see if this helps, or I may sell it on to someone with easier soils and get a model with stiffer tines.

Mine also bent in our rocky soil.  If I ever get another, I will probably get a Meadow Creature, which seems to have reinforced, blade-like tines.

This is the kind that I use. Probably only available in Australia, but I can recommend it: https://www.fdryan.com/store/p69/broadfork.html

That looks like it could actually be fun - if not for my land being almost entirely one, big rock. I think a smaller version might do better for me - is there such a thing?

They are fun : )

I wonder if this one would work for you on any not-so-rocky bits Carla? It has shorter tines and width than the one I use: https://meadowcreature.com/collections/frontpage/products/peoples-broadfork-12

Ooooooo! Definite possibilities, there!! Thank you!

Way Cool Tools also make a range of "Unbreakable" broadforks in various sizes : https://waycooltools.com/t/broadforks

I have not purchased one yet but am trying to make up my mind which size to get...

This is the one I use from Jonny Seeds. I've used it mostly on established beds but I also used it to reseed a freshly created berm. I love it for prepping beds for root veggies!

I love my Meadow Creature! We don't have rocks, but we do have roots that may as well be! I can use the broadfork to pull them up closer to the surface to get cut with a pruner or the grub hoe so they can get pulled out in pieces. Before the Creature we had to prep new planting areas with a pickaxe! This is much easier...and more fun

I love my Meadow Creature broad fork too! I use it to break up beds before planting, and for ripping apart sod in fields when planting trees.  If I could go back in time, this would be one of my first purchases.

I watched a Charles Dowding video where he did a casual comparison of a no dig bed vs one that had been broadforked and the no dig bed won. His guess was that forking damages soil fungi.

My garden has clay soil so heavy that it's busted BOTH rototillers we've borrowed from our long-suffering neighbors. Now, the first step in my bed prep is using a spading fork in the same manner as a broadfork. If I don't, germination suffers. After forking I pull weeds, which helps break up big clods. After planting I mulch generously with young, juicy mown/pulled weeds.

I dream of a lovely broad broadfork with easier lever action that would make bed prep faster than my narrow fork. I also dream of the day when my soil has better tilth. I'm amping up the cover cropping, mulching like a madman, and limiting "invasive tool use" to the fork. But if I don't do ANY forking, the soil behaves like actual concrete.

TL/DR: Prepping beds with a fork improves germination in heavy clay Kansas soils that behave like concrete.

I have the same problem with concrete. Tillers don't stand a chance. Meadow creature broadfork loosend it up till summer rains packed it back down. My main kitchen garden took 3 years to be able to properly grow good veg.  I had to add about 2 ft. of hay every fall to rot down, added 1000s of earthworms and grew lots of dikon radish's and left to rot in ground.  ( those things really drill through hard-pan and clay).  Finally I can dig down 8-10 inches with my hands alone. Its been many years. Still add a foot or two of hay to rot down every fall. just part the hay where I want rows,shove broadfork deep down and wiggle it, add a little compost on top for seeds, or just set starts in the earth. Years of rotting hay has made the difference.

I haven't tried the daikons or oilseed radish yet. Thanks for the reminder.

How long do the roots generally take to break down? And do you think it would make a good cattle forage while still benefiting soil? I have two dairy Dexters that might enjoy the variety.

I haven't gone in in buying a broad fork because rocks are my main soil issue.
I have tried torpedo radishes, to no avail.
They're great,  but they can't break up rocks,  go figure.
I find their leaves and seedpods to be tasty,  but the big roots are just too darn hot, even after slow roasting.
The Dexter cows might not mind the heat.

our wet winters causes them to rot fairly quick, say  before starting other plants in spring..  I do sow them very thick.   I like the taste of them and so do my animals, just so many radish you can use though.
Seed is cheap.  Others in my area have hauled in soil, built raised beds etc....I just took the slow route.  I have many seperate garden beds where I just built yearly compost piles. started new piles elsewhere the following year and piled on 6-8 inches of fresh cow manure for another year then planted there.  Soil probably hard under there but i don't disturb soil, just grow stuff. guess I got more time than money.

I'm going to put in a word for broadforks, even on a rocky terrain. We have rocky soil—we're not just in the Ozarks, but on a ridge, so we're up where a lot of the topsoil has washed away and left ground that's absolutely full of limestone. Then it has been badly compacted by the builders who put in our home.

We decided to buy a broadfork because I couldn't see using a tiller on such rocky soil—I think the common garden ones would bounce right off. And we're not working at a scale large enough to get in a tractor on our half-acre suburbanish lot. So we bought the Meadow Creature broadfork, and it has held up for two years to a lot of abuse. I have used it to pry up limestone, to pull down some rotting timber retaining walls, and to dig up the "stumps" of the ornamental grasses we had planted all over the property. It hasn't shown any damage. I'm sure we would have broken one of the less robust ones by now.

Of course, using it on our soils is no joke. I often have to jump up and down on it or angle it in different directions to get it in, and on the first year with a bed I can't usually work more than the top 3-4 inches of soil. On the other hand, it's not so strenuous that my wife (who's a very small person) can't use it, and in our second year broadforking our garden beds was much less difficult. We did pull a lot of rock out of the ground by hand each time, and I suspect that is going to be an annual chore.

So I'd say don't give up on (heavy-duty) broadforks if you have rocky ground. For our small-scale garden, I don't think there's a better tool for the job.

Nick Neufeld wrote:I watched a Charles Dowding video where he did a casual comparison of a no dig bed vs one that had been broadforked and the no dig bed won. His guess was that forking damages soil fungi.

Interesting results.

I have a large amount of rock in my loamy soil, would a broadfork still work for me?

My main interest is to use it to break up compaction layers as well doing initial till on new garden space.

Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

Depends on the size of the rocks, and how deep they tend to be...at my place there are areas that are no-broadfork zones because there are too many fist-sized and larger rocks within striking distance, and my broadfork has curved tines made from round bar steel, which are prone to bending (I've already reinforced the outer ones with gussets because of this).

Bought an inexpensive one because my soil (sand) is easy to work with.

https://www.zoro.com/bully-tools-broadfork-10-ga-steel-fiberglass-handle-56-x-20-x-525-in-92627/i/G1274321/


It's great for starting and renovating beds.

I'm lazy so I'll push the handles down until I can get a foot on one of them to push down and  flip the dirt.

No dig is great, but a lot of what I grow are root crops, so digging is inevitable.

Seems no dig has you "digging" more than traditional methods, in the sense of having to shovel and move a LOT of compost to make it work.

Not all no-dig methods are the same. I only dig when there is something underground I need to get, like kūmara or spuds, or when I have a tree to plant. But I don't move much compost...nowadays nearly all the compost I use goes into potting mix or tree planting, not on garden or cropping beds. I spread wood chips and green chop-n-drop mulch. Yes, that's still movement of materials, but wood chips and grass are a lot less dense than compost so I'll take that tradeoff.

I bought a broad fork a few years back. It was custom fabricated. Someone else’s design. It looked a lot like the photos Kate Downham posted of the broad fork she recommends.

I just thought the design sold by Johnny Seeds looked like it would only work in fluffy fine grained soil, the lind of soil that no longer needs a broadfork. I thought the wooden handles would break where they joined the metal teeth assembly.

I had heavy clay soil, and I thought my broadfork was fabulous for loosening a century’s worth of compaction, for changing the texture of the soil and enhancing access for earth worms and other organisms that live in the soil, transform dirt to soil.

I did not try to break up the clods. I was more breaking the monolithic concrete like substrate into head sized clods. I tried to encourage organic matter and sand into the channels between the clods.

Worked great!

forgot to mention.....

After pushing it down with my foot I have a string tied to one handle with the other end in a loop that goes around my wrist to pull the handles back up.

This way I don't have to bend over on every stroke to retrieve the handles.

I'd never heard of the Meadow Creature or seen any of the styles that earlier posters show. The broadfork I've used for decades (https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop/garden/garden-care/cultivators/10521-lee-valley-u-bar-digger) has very strong tines. I don't think it would be possible to bend a tine on a rock, as mentioned in an earlier post. Lee Valley says it won't work with clay, but I can confirm that it works with clay loam that isn't too dry. I used it instead of a tiller to break ground for a new garden bed. It was a good workout, but the strength and leverage of the tool made it feasible. Any soil you can force the tines into by standing on the crossbar will yield to its might. It's a power fork!  Now I just use it to loosen the soil in the garden beds in spring.

Hey guys, help me out. Dear Wife has Amazon Prime shipping, ending tomorrow.

I came across this reasonably priced broadfork and it *seems* like what I've been trying to find for a long time.

I'll be using it in both sandy and clay soils (esp. harvesting root veg in the clay). It looks tough enough to do the job.

What do you think? Worth buying?

https://www.amazon.ca/VVOKGO-Broadfork-Gardening-Unbreakable-Crushing/dp/B0G43JHD9P/ref=sr_1_6?crid=ZQHDNM7X082O&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.BDJq-JErz7v9wLy5BHMDHsWclKAeLWJ36h4FSPi67rnQt_HHq6pVuO6SB0oNezSkdiJlH_YAM87sAzSTHQKOTVUmiQt7tq6koxb5isLT9h1CEtE9GtTh9YT3Ygiv996k3JRnTV9gbo7A3aN7ukhEHugCIFKbwyBg4iSigSIQEqWVydnLuDjrtqm4aF-8e-rT86PuhJl-AQ1SZEZ40UzCfF35fJBiE0vKlRTg2w_VrDRU9PTNQgZQDjKVlNRXqtgDKheDk9TFcpJ6xcUBZnJef6yGOro4NZjbHLmY4-1sNGU.ZcKoP-YCkH1UYH-F-VQCUyneJNDPvlHr47XdGJT4AgQ&dib_tag=se&keywords=broadfork&qid=1776039733&sprefix=broadfork%2Caps%2C203&sr=8-6

I don't know Douglas.  I am always wary of those 'metric' broadforks.  I think the SAE or Imperial garden tools are superior.  But it may work for you in the Great White North.  :)

Douglas Alpenstock wrote:Hey guys, help me out. Dear Wife has Amazon Prime shipping, ending tomorrow.

I came across this reasonably priced broadfork and it *seems* like what I've been trying to find for a long time.

I'll be using it in both sandy and clay soils (esp. harvesting root veg in the clay). It looks tough enough to do the job.

What do you think? Worth buying?

It doesn't look as hefty as the one from Lee Valley that I noted last year, but it's less than half the price and looks sturdy enough for previously loosened soil.

I am skeptical, I think it looks more “light to medium” than heavy duty.  It looks like the handles have a joint in the middle.

It will work in some situations as in previously loosened soil, but dense solid clay is another thing entirely.

It also looks like the tines are extended in a straight line from the handle… to pull the handles back and lift the tines through the soil is going to require more effort than pushing them down, where you can put your body weight into it.

But, if the postage is paid to return it, you can always return it.

Thanks all. I'll pass on it then.

It does look a lot beefier in the photos in the actual listing. But I'm skeptical of any garden tool made offshore unless I can see it in a shop and put my weight on it. You can't tell the strength of the tines from a photo.

The Lee Valley digger is clearly labelled as "not suitable for clay soils." I've looked at them at LV and they don't seem strong enough for my uses.

Unfortunately all other options are too expensive. Up here, a Meadow Creature, for example, would be over $600 CAD with shipping.

Douglas Alpenstock wrote:
The Lee Valley digger is clearly labelled as "not suitable for clay soils." I've looked at them at LV and they don't seem strong enough for my uses.

If that digger isn't strong enough for you, you must be aiming to dig into unworked clay, which is likely what the LV disclaimer means. I consider that to be a pickaxe job! What root crops can grow in clay?

Have you considered getting a local welder to fabricate a digger to your specs? Thekla's observation about the angle between the handles and tines is relevant. I find the LV design to be optimal for my arm length, allowing me to stand on the crossbar to drive the tines in while holding the handgrips and then prying the soil loose when I pull the handles back and down. The catalog pictures don't show it, but if the soil is tight I stand (or even jump) on the crossbar with both feet.  A design with only 3 or 4 tines would have even more soil ripping power.

David Wieland wrote:

Douglas Alpenstock wrote:
The Lee Valley digger is clearly labelled as "not suitable for clay soils." I've looked at them at LV and they don't seem strong enough for my uses.

If that digger isn't strong enough for you, you must be aiming to dig into unworked clay, which is likely what the LV disclaimer means. I consider that to be a pickaxe job! What root crops can grow in clay?

Based on what you say, I may give the Lee Valley digger another look.

With the weird spells of drought we've been having, nice clay soil with plenty of organic matter can dry into hard blocks. One year we loosened the potato patch with a Bobcat (after breaking two stout hand implements). This year I bought a 3 pt. hitch middle buster to mount on a small tractor if needed.