posted 12 years ago
Hello Folks,
Just so everyone reading this knows, Brian and I know each other in a since. We both work in the alternative/green architecture field; I as a timber wright and Brian as a design builder, and someone I would call a friend. I'm sure he and I will discuss this offline as well, but it is good to hear this kind of discussion that folk like Brian and I can have about subjects like this. He is an outstanding professional in the field of alternative/green architecture, and I wouldn't want anyone to think I don't respect him by my comments or observations. This is a good example for folks to learn about regional difference in approaches to things and also how a region can be change based on understanding those differences.
I'm in Vermont where a dark roof makes more since and Brian is down South. This is one really good reason to have a lighter colored roof, if you can get by the aesthetics. If you can't you are going to have to insure a "breathing roof," design is used to offset the heat gained by a dark roof.
Now for the type of metal roof:
This is where we can all learn a little something, because I'm sure Brian will fill us in on what he is seeing in his area. Standing seam metal roof in my area cost between $250 to $350 per square. (a square in roofing equals 100 square feet.) Metal roofing with screw down fasteners is $175 to $300 per square, not a big difference. Now lets assume the average roof is about 1500 square feet. At the current rate of $3.5 per square foot (plus materials,)to replace the screws on a fasten down roof, you are going to spend $5250.00 plus materials every 15 to 20 years. That is assuming that the cost of the service and materials does not increase over those years. I have seen standing seam roofs sell for as much as $500.00 to $800.00 per square in some regions, just because it was a novelty and only the wealthier clients could afford it. These are the kinds of things the consumer must research when building. Often they can change a trend by bringing a contractor from a different region to work in theirs.
Now for the sod roof issue, you never want an "earth/wet" roof on metal, only rubber and clay. As for the original poster questions. You will have to do some math, as I said, and probably talk to a P.E. to get it to work on your roof. Now lets suppose the math works out for you. If you called me and asked what I would do, this is it:
We are assuming the numbers worked and the pitch is 6/12 or less.
I would have you collect as much scrap new paper as you could get over the next year, then save enough to buy a rubber pond liner to cover the entire roof. Next you are going to get as much used felt carpet padding as your local carpet store can get you. You are going to pull out all the staples and stock pile this until you have enough to cover the roof plus overlaps of 300 mm (12"). You are going to find a source that can bring you a loud of dry clay soil, (preferably a bentonite variety,) that will cover the roof area by at least 30 mm (1.25"). A nylon mesh netting to cover the roof area if you plantings are going to be from seed. Now choose you plant life that you are going to use.
If you are still reading this and want the next step, ask your questions now.
Regards, jay