I live in Western Maryland. The main asset of this area is a low turnover of neighbors. I have lived here 16 years and I am still the newcomer on my road. And I can tell you from personal
experience, that I have the best neighbors and friends on the planet in this area. Garrett County people are awesome. Just plain mountain folk. The kind that work hard, are honest, and willing to help.
None around me are
permaculture; however,
permaculture people fit right in. When I first moved in, I gained a reputation for being Amish because I was doing things very differently on this land. There are Amish living around me, so this is an understandable error.
Land around Deep Creek is pricey. But most of Garrett County is reasonably priced.
I have not once lacked
water since moving here. My property does not have a spring or creek, but it is easy to find properties that do. Rainfall is frequent.
You can have as much privacy as you want.
I am not into art so I cannot tell if there is a lot of
local activity in the arts, but I can tell you that at no time have I been hassled about owning an
outhouse, my
humanure pile, etc. Just do what you want, and as long as you don't step on neighbor's toes - your left alone. You cannot find any local government without a few anal-retentive idiots. However, I have not run into a lot of them. Store a shovel in your outhouse and its a garden shed which is legal.
Neighbors around me leave their keys in the vehicles so the keys don't get lost. There has not been one thing stolen from my property - except produce by !@#$ raccoons and squirrels.
Where ever you move to, I wish you the best.