Nicole Alderman wrote:
Debi Baker wrote:The borax free recipes you posted would still be bad for the soil. Salt is real bad for the soil. All fabric bleach, etc... And the ph is high
We do often get away with it if it is not much at once or diluted. Maybe a biological treatment could get rid of it.
But oasis can be used with no treatment and actually Feeds the plants. Dr Bronners and Ecos are reported to be next best safest
I went and looked up the ingredients in Oasis's laundry detergent.
Concentrated Laundry Liquid
Water
Linear Alkyl Sulfonate (a biodegradable detergent)
Linear Alcohol Ethoxylate (a biodegradable detergent)
Triethanolamine (aka T.E.A. biodegradable enhancer of oil solubility and Ph)
d-Limonene (naturally derived citrus oil – a fragrance from citrus peels)
Glutaraldehyde (biodegradable preservative)
The same company also sells other biodegradble products, such as a powder detergent http://www.bio-pac.com/products/
Concentrated (Ultra) Laundry Powder
Sodium Carbonate (occurs naturally – used for water softening)
Sodium Metasilicate Pentahydrate (biodegradable detergent)
Zeolite (naturally occurring mineral)
Linear Alcohol Ethoxylate (a biodegradable detergent)
Carboxy Methyl Cellulose (anti-redeposition agent)
Sodium Chloride (common salt)
Linear Alkyl Sulfonate (a biodegradable detergent)
d-Limonene (naturally derived citrus oil – a fragrance from citrus peels)
There's washing soda and salt in that, and they also sell oxygen bleach.
Are the only concerns about washing soda, baking soda, and oxygen bleach (which is made by mixing baking soda with hydrogen peroxide), that they are too alkaline? I went and looked up some of the ingredients in the detergents in the Environmental Working Group to see their safety for humans (which may be different than for green water systems, but is important to me as they will be against my skin).
Ingredients in Oasis Liquid Detergent:
linear alkylbenzene sulfonate-- given a grade of C. toxic to anerobic digestion. and is considered toxic to aquatic life Linear Alcohol Ethoxylate given a grade of D for causing cancer and gentic defects and reproductive toxicity, amoung other things Triethanolamine gets a grade of D for reproductive and developmental toxicity and cancer and more d-Limonene gets a grade of C for toxicity to aquatic animals and skin irritant. This surprised me, because it's jusr an extract from citruc peals, and I make my limonene cleaner by soaking them in vinegar Glutaraldehyde gets a grade of F! For skin burns and being very toxic to aquatic life
Ingredients in Borax-free recipes (I also listed the ratings from The Environmental Working Group's cosmetics site, which rates things on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the most dangerous. I'd found them before I found the other EWG site. So, I listed both here)
washing soda comes at the lowest score of 1, being very safe. Given a grade of A Oxygen Bleach has score of 2. It's not related to chlorine bleach at all, and can be made by mixing hydrogen peroxide and baking soda. Gets a grade of B Baking soda has a score of 1, and a grade of A
My soil is acidic. I'm going to assume that adding some alkaline cleaners isn't that bad if they are non-toxic and not dangerous to aquatic life. I'm not sure of their affects on plants, but I'd rather have safe chemicals on my clothes than more dangerous ones... I've learned a lot through looking all that up--it was surprising to see things listed in an eco-friendly soap be listed as dangerous to humans and aquatic life. I wasn't expecting that at all!