ediblecities wrote:
That's not true. There are several seeds which need the boiling water treatment.
I forgot this when I tried to raise tagasaste and failed. Some seeds even need fire.
If you want rare seeds try at horizon.
Yes, as I said in my post, there are serotinous species (including many pines) that need fire to open the cone, and/or to change the seed coat to allow water in. But if the temperature of the embryo plant within the seed is raised anywhere close to boiling (much less 700 degrees F of a fire), that is going to kill the seed.
In this US Forest Service page that advocates the use of boiling water to help break seed-coat dormancy, they warn that "
Hot water can kill the seed - it is important not to soak the seed for too long!" The smaller the seed, the larger the volume of the water, or the longer the time, the greater the chance that the plant inside the seed is exposed to deadly temperature. If the rooibos seeds are small and are soaked in a much larger volume of boiling water, or soaked for too long, they will not germinate - they will be killed. I suspect it is rather easy to overdo the boiling water treatment, especially when the people promoting it (as with my original post) are quite vague about it. I greatly prefer mechanical scarification, as there is usually lots of room for error; chemical scarification comes in second, and boiling water is third unless there is a proven protocol for a species.
http://www.winrock.org/fnrm/factnet/FACTPUB/AIS_web/AIS12.html