Bryant RedHawk wrote:The girdling method is most often used (by me) for changing the root pattern of Bonsai Trees, where you really want even spacing all around the trunk of the tree.
Even when doing this I do not completely girdle the tree since that makes it a live or die situation and with my Bonsai trees selling for 50 to 500 dollars, I really don't want to loose a few years work.
I have no idea why so many people seem to think this is good method, perhaps they think it will make better roots?
I always put it forth like this: If you want to kill a tree, you girdle it, this stops all nutrient flow in the tree and it will most assuredly die.
What I have always wondered is how many of the people recommending this method actually do air layering or grafting on a regular basis and if they do, what is their success rate?
I've never seen anyone touting girdling for layering mention their own success rate or how many they do in a year.
I think it is one of those urban legends that people read and say "well, of course" and then they spread it around like they know what they are talking about, but they are actually clueless.