Kevin Stanton

+ Follow
since Jun 05, 2021
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
Biography
Looking at permaculture from a dryland megaproject that has a lot of water in 2026
For More
usa
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
4
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Kevin Stanton

Joao Winckler wrote:Only roots I've really had to think about are fruit tree rootstocks. Dwarfing ones like M9 stay shallow and need a stake forever, seedling stock goes deep and anchors itself. Never looked at it as erosion control though, that's a good angle for a prototype area.


What deep root did you combine with this to drive them deeper?
6 days ago

Joseph Lofthouse wrote:To me, out-of-sight, out-of-mind.



That's nice, but what if you need to worry about an area as the prototype for a large scale area, that has all of the "topsoil" going into the river, you're thinking about things differently than a small project.
6 days ago

Anne Miller wrote:Will these logs be used like a dam?



No, a micro-hügelkultur
6 days ago

Robert Ray wrote:
Have you been on site yet?


Seen plenty of pictures, and they're already asking for hydrating the land advice, moving this week. I told them build a water diaper for overflow, and mega-berms to hold the water back from the dams to help out the state/community.

Robert Ray wrote:
Strip  mine like, the initial description, or a truly reclaimed strip mine that would have to have been covered with the original topsoil and plants upon cessation of mining. In the US the site is required to be  restored to a contour has to be above or equal to previous contour, so I am wondering about "amount of material removed" means.


Yes, a high mountain strip mine.

Robert Ray wrote:
A proposed data center on Federal land? If on Federal land that use wouldn't have any bearing on the private property project. If it does how?  What is its significance and area of disturbance on the project property.


The significance is essentially 1 of the 2 places of hydration for aquafer. How do you disturb the soil more than a canceled mega-building (data center), and strip mine?

Robert Ray wrote:
What does Stamets e-coli experience have anything to do with your proposed project other than the flow through component?


There was a major drop of livestock carried diseases from a mushroom farm being downstream of a cattle ranch, and with a fungal dominated soil, it will treat the diseases of concern.

Robert Ray wrote:
There are people here from all over the globe, they wouldn't know anything about US policies unless one makes them aware.


Ray Archuletta, Gabe Brown, Joel Salatin, et al are.

Robert Ray wrote:
10k of flat ground as initially described or 10k of mountainous and flat ground? This would be important for educated answers and solutions. Is it flat that requires no topographical info as you previously indicated?


It's larger than 10k acres.

Robert Ray wrote:
40 mil budget. Is there any machinery, housing, cattle over and above that 40 mil? Is the 40 mil the absolute budget?


Yes, the works.

Robert Ray wrote:
15 sq miles how fast do you see the project coming together? Earthwork, cross fencing, seeding, stock on the ground. Is it going to be done in increments or all in at the beginning.


In the "cheat year", I see it coming together a lot faster than in a non-cheat year similarly to the success of Alejandro Carrillo.

Robert Ray wrote:
If there is a mountainous component in the 10k what is that size. Its use would be far different as far as flat ground pasture. That difference would also influence AU productivity. What is the true topography? If there is an elevation component now, we can add many other water saving/gathering components. If so, area of and elevation information. Knowing where the mountainous area is on the projects site might influence rain and rain shadow influence computations.


The Mountains are larger than a MN ski mountain.
1k AU is just a starting number, plan to up it when the hay supplementation can go away.

Robert Ray wrote:
Since we are talking creating a forage source I am puzzled by the fear of plant oxidation creating a fire hazard. To bring the proposed 1AU per acre there is going to be seasonal plant material on the site. My research into the Australians and Argentina impression trial sites made no reference to increased fire danger being a concern. It appears in fact that there is increased water retention, that would decrease fire hazard. I found no fire dangers concerns in the PDF papers from the US as of yet.


Even if you can't see the root, or leaves doesn't mean the plant/tree is dead.
The plant oxidation is a mention to Alan Savory, and when the animals came back the grass stayed green and less flammable.

Robert Ray wrote:
What state? Knowing this would help in making comments on what the water Gods of that state allows.


US part of the Chihuahuan desert.

Robert Ray wrote:
State of Emergency Flood Plains usually are in areas in which infrastructure, populations and escape routes are in jeopardy "during" a flood. Right now the S.W. is getting hammered. Is your project site close to a population center? Major highway? Utility infrastructure? What components will support an Emergency Flood Plan request that could release monies to implement and enhance your project?


The state of emergency I'm talking about is only when ranchers fail to plan for flooding. Look into Gabe Browns ( https://www.ted.com/talks/gabe_brown_how_regenerative_agriculture_brings_life_back_to_the_land ) water infiltration story. Imagine that happening in the desert.

Robert Ray wrote:
This is a huge admirable project. Getting a true sense of budget, location, topography will allow folks to drill down to suggestions that are pertinent to your goals and location.


Thanks, just need to ask all my questions to hit the ground running as fast as possible saying "try this", "do this".
1 week ago

Phil Stevens wrote:I've never tried logs myself apart from having larger branch sections that I left on the ground take root. A log crosswise to a sheet flood is going to roll and if it's not really well rooted it will get swept away. Think about the force of moving water, plus all the mud and silt, and how it interacts with the landscape during a flood event. Poles stuck deep into the ground and presenting a minimal cross section to the current stand a decent chance of staying in place. Logs lengthwise and secured (with pegs and wire maybe) might hold. But logs standing abreast of a wall of water are asking for a quick trip to the next county downstream.



When you cut large trees down they send up more trees, so for propagating a new area not directly in the river/stream (mud with rocks over it, since I have more rocks than I need) if it can hold close to the water table I was thinking it would send up trees along the length, and root. I should mention it's standing water right now if I want it to be standing.

So did the logs propagate as well as the "stems"?
1 week ago

Anne Miller wrote:Since you are interested in roots, you or others might find these interesting:

https://permies.com/t/38508/weeds-compete

https://permies.com/t/390438/noteworthy-roots



This is good, when people "know" what grass, and a root are, and don't think erosion is normal.

They also consider seasonal flooding something that makes land worthless (conversation with a real estate agent).
1 week ago

Timothy Norton wrote:A book that helped me better understand the variations/types of plant roots is Roots Demystified by Robert Kourik. There is a more recent book written by Robert Kourik titled Understanding Roots that is aid to have even more information compared to the older book but I have yet to read it.

I still am learning how to best incorporate particular root systems into my landscape planning so I can't provide advice but I'm right there with you trying to learn as much as I can! :)



What if I'm teaching people without looking to dig into a book? I want a simple answer for when people ask about plant diversity that will trigger a lightbulb.
1 week ago

Phil Stevens wrote:Our regional council uses willow poles to stabilise river banks. They put in a whole bunch nearby several years ago after a flood event started scouring out a soft bank of pure silt that supported an ecologically significant patch of forest and protected a major highway bridge approach. Since then there have been quite a few similar-sized floods, maybe one or two even higher, and the willows have held the line.



But what about single logs in a hugelkultur technique for lots of trees?
1 week ago
When "planning" a root system, how do you think of different root styles?

I'm thinking:
surface roots - hold the surface dirt from breaking apart
deep roots - staple the dirt into place to prevent massive landslides
1 week ago