Douglas Alpenstock wrote:Well I'm sure the tools exist for a full snapshot.
Asking permission is nice, remarkably old school.
The question is, what's in it for Paul?
Nothing. Already excited about the constant scouring of the site by AI agents based on remarkable number of pageviews/huge bandwidth usage, what is the difference?
Taking advantage of interest, now, seems like a good idea.
Put together a compendium of knowledge, condensing it. Most of every page on this site is just neighborly conversation.
The information provided by AI will certainly follow the Silicon Valley model of free until they decide you are hooked, then paid subscription only.
There will be people who can afford to/or will pay, and those who can't/don't. Only the most basic, useless will be free. Agentic AI is already pay only, and prices will go up. Society, I believe, will be divided between those with assets and those without. Those with full access to instant knowledge and those without. Those with useful skills and those without.
There are those who want/tolerate community.
There are those like myself who write in order to think, and prefer a hard copy, paper. I dislike digital reading. I prefer pages to flip, tabs to keep open, time to read when there is no power/bandwidth, no glaring electronic background. Having to run precious, off grid power just to think is way, way short sighted. Kids don't seem to grow up with physical access to analogue, ad free, permanent knowledge in their hands.
Forums in general are declining from the 2010's peak, I can see that. People want instant answers. Forums can only serve those who choose them.
Folks have been migrating to the instant, effortless, critical thought free knowledge of a curated internet. Wading through opinion/chatter in search of facts is tiring. Forums will be irrelevant to anyone not seeking writing or community.
Most topics are already covered by digital downloads and podcasts on this website.
There are many publishers who will convert any digital file you send them into bound paper copy.
Here is one:
https://www.iuniverse.com/en
They published a cool paperback about the 1911 baseball season I just read.
I don't envy anyone involved here on the 'stewardship' end. Community is by it's nature free, or maybe a barter of (hopefully knowledgeable) speech/conversation. Finding way to monetize community in order to keep the lights on and hopefully spread the knowledge, seems a difficult act.
Figuring out how to serve the widest audience seems fundamental.