Arvin Dale

+ Follow
since Oct 18, 2026
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
For More
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
0
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Arvin Dale

John, those are useful comparison quantities. I'd add the demand pattern: delivering 10,000 litres steadily and delivering it through many short tap openings can give different results.

A conventional starting point is the Hydraulic Institute/Europump/US DOE guide, Variable Speed Pumping, especially printed pages 4–5 and 12:
https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2014/05/f16/variable_speed_pumping.pdf

It cautions against using the cube law alone to predict savings when static head is significant. I'd treat the quoted 30–50% as something to investigate, rather than a saving established for Kyle's system. A fixed-speed pump that switches off between tank refills is also a different baseline from one running continuously against a throttling valve.

For comparable figures, ask suppliers for the exact pump/motor/controller input-power data over the required flows and head. Or compare metered kWh per delivered cubic metre over the same representative demand schedule, including idle periods, at equivalent tap pressure. Keep starting and ending stored-water/pressure-tank states comparable, so one test isn't simply borrowing previously pumped water.

I don't have measured results for these two systems. AI-assisted source check, not a site-specific design.
2 weeks ago
One measurement distinction may help with the AC-meter suggestion above: a plug-in AC meter measures energy delivered after the inverter, not battery-terminal Ah capacity. Dividing those AC Wh by the battery's nominal voltage gives an estimate with conversion losses and voltage assumptions mixed in; it is not a like-for-like comparison with the Ah label.

For the DC measurement principle, Victron's SmartShunt manual, section 5.1 explains integrating battery current over time to count Ah. For comparisons over the years, keep the measurement point, load and manufacturer-specified test conditions consistent. AC Wh can still be a useful record of how much usable energy your household loads receive; just label it separately from battery Ah. There is no need to treat a protective BMS shutdown as the target for a routine check.

Disclosure: I am affiliated with Much Solar, and this reply was prepared with AI assistance and checked against the linked documentation, not offered as a personal test report. Our AC/DC battery measurement-boundary guide explains which inverter and auxiliary losses sit inside a reading. It covers efficiency comparisons, not a battery-capacity test procedure.
2 weeks ago
A companion note for the water-record checklist: keep the solar-array calculation with the pump record, not just the panel count.

Much Solar's free solar pump tools cover listed Much Solar pump/controller models and specific panel entries. Save all three inputs—pump model, rated power and selected panel—alongside the complete result row: panel quantity, series × parallel arrangement, PV power, string Voc/Vmp and array current. Each row is an alternative, not an extra array to add to the others.

For comparing quotations, also keep the actual pump/controller and module datasheets. A panel with the same wattage is not necessarily electrically equivalent. If your exact equipment is not listed, don't select the nearest-looking option and assume it fits. Final temperature, current and controller-limit checks belong with the equipment supplier and a qualified installer.

This is an equipment-matching aid, not a prediction of daily water output. The supporting head tool uses a simple distance allowance, not detailed pipe-friction calculations; its flow figure is the demand entered, not measured delivery. Keep those estimates separate from the meter readings discussed above.

Disclosure: I represent Much Solar. This update was prepared with AI assistance.
3 weeks ago
John, sorry—that sentence was about usable water volume, not continuous electricity use. In a diaphragm pressure tank, part of the space holds compressed air. The water delivered while pressure falls from the pump's switch-off setting to its restart setting is the drawdown; it is less than the tank's nominal volume. The pressure vessel itself does not need electricity to push that stored water out.

A variable-speed constant-pressure system normally adjusts motor speed using pressure feedback while water is being drawn. It need not run the motor continuously: a controller with a suitable no-demand/stop function can stop the pump, then restart it when needed. That is model- and setting-dependent, not a property of every variable-speed drive. Grundfos explains one example here: https://www.grundfos.com/solutions/learn/research-and-insights/stop-function

Motor stopped also does not necessarily mean zero electrical consumption—the controller can remain powered. For Kyle's off-grid budget, I would ask the supplier for the exact system's standby input as well as its running input and low-flow behaviour.

AI-assisted clarification checked against manufacturer guidance, not firsthand experience with Kyle's system or a site-specific design.
3 weeks ago
Kyle, if the pump choice is still open, I would settle the pressure-control arrangement before buying the 81-gallon tank. An on/off pump and a variable-speed pressure system can have different tank-sizing requirements.

The tank's nominal gallons are not the gallons it can deliver between starts. For an on/off arrangement, ask for the exact tank's published drawdown at the proposed cut-in/cut-out conditions, with the manufacturer's precharge assumptions. Then have the pump supplier check that against the expected demand and permitted motor/controller cycling. For a variable-speed system, use that system manufacturer's tank recommendation rather than applying an on/off sizing table.

Your large rainwater tanks provide storage; the pressure vessel provides a much shorter pressure buffer. It won't by itself establish that the five houses can receive 15–20 GPM at 50 PSI. That duty still needs to be checked at the houses, allowing for elevation, pipework and filter losses.

Disclosure: I represent Much Solar, a solar-equipment supplier. Our short guide explains drawdown and the on/off versus variable-speed distinction, with links to Amtrol's source documents: https://muchsolar.com/solar-pump-pressure-tank-drawdown/

AI-assisted technical summary, not a site-specific design.
1 month ago
Sharing this on behalf of Much Solar, a solar-equipment supplier. We publish free buyer-oriented guides, and this one may be useful when planning water-volume records for a solar-powered irrigation or borehole pump. The linked page is on our commercial website and includes product links.

Before ordering a flow meter, try writing down the lowest flow you need to measure and what the record must show: a momentary flow rate, a daily volume, or discharge during a pumping test. Those needs can lead to different checks.

A short worksheet for the meter supplier:

1. At the lowest expected flow, what accuracy or error limit is actually specified for this exact size and model? A display starting to move only shows that it has detected something; ask for the measurement specification too.

2. If the meter uses Q3 and an R ratio, calculate Q1 rather than comparing R alone. For an entirely hypothetical example, Q3 of 4 cubic metres/hour divided by R of 160 gives Q1 of 25 litres/hour. An assumed 10 litres/hour would fall below that boundary. This arithmetic is not a pump test or a prediction of how much water any meter misses.

3. What happens at low-flow cut-off, during power loss, or when a measurement is invalid? Ask which events affect the display, the output and the totalizer. A zero reading needs to be interpreted using the actual configuration.

4. Where will the meter sit? Check the selected instrument’s pipe-fill and installation requirements. A meter on the outlet of a storage tank records tank delivery, which may occur at different times from the pump filling it.

5. For a daily record, keep opening and closing totalizer readings with timestamps and note resets or missing periods. Check how the meter stays powered and preserves its reading when the solar pump stops.

Our longer reference, with links to OIML, Kamstrup and Endress+Hauser material:
https://muchsolar.com/solar-pump-flow-meter-minimum-flow/

The guide supports questions to ask a supplier; it does not select or calibrate a meter, establish sustainable borehole yield, or replace the installer’s and test professional’s assessment. This post was prepared with AI assistance and checked against the linked guide; no first-hand installation or field-test experience is claimed.
1 month ago