Hello, friends,
I made this account specially to reply to this thread
I'm from Romania, but i have lot of experience with CFL-s. I work as electrician for a france-nigerian joint venture.
Yes, they are not as good as the claims are.
But still are some brands who make good quality - not perfect, because these CFL-s are simply too new to be perfect.
It was already shown up in this thread that the lifespan is decreased by the number of switching's.
The lifespan for an Osram reached 20000 switching's for a 24W model 3U, warm white, and have a life expectancy of 10000 hours; They are really try to do these things better. On the other way, Philips were dissapointing me - the last batches of CFL's didn't last more than 2 years in places where the time per day was approx 4 hours and 4 switching operations per day
The light is 4 times more than incandescent for the first half life of the product, and than decrease to three times, slowly till the end of life.
As it was specified in a post previously, the life span declared is an average half-life, like that what is used for measuring the decay of radioactive isothopes. That is, if you have 100 bulbs or CFL-s rated for 5000 hours, after 5000 hours will be 50 bulbs alive; and should be 25 after 10000 hours - but here this ratio is really not so applicable....
The switching process remove material from the cathodes - this will short the life span. Osram simply put more matherial on their cathodes, this made bulbs to have a life longer.
The heat destroy the electrolytic capacitors inside the bulb. As an average capacitor is rated to survive 2000 hours at 105 degree celsius, if is good quality - or 85 degree for other cheaper family of capacitors. But also heat will reduce the lifespan of semiconductors, by electromigration and difussion of connection materials inside the lattice of semiconductor.
Osram made a good product.
Well, now about new tendencies.
Cree, a big LED manufacturer, have worked on the LED issues, and after a few years of improvement and finally just arrived with something good and
cheap as dirt (for me, really that's cheap - and i'm not a rich man):
Check these on google: CXA-2011 and XM-L family - if you want to build LED lamps, try these, but choose the warm white - for me, cold is simply too actinic and nasty.
I've tried one CXA-2011 on a processor heatsink, it's very easy to mount; supplied by a special current supply - not VOLTAGE supply; a current supply will simply deliver a constant current regardless of voltage absorbed by the load
well, it was a 40....50V at fix 1 Ampere power supply; the light amount is simply amazing, is approaching that of a 300 W HALOGEN LINEAR BULB. it was not exactly that amount, but close; i can approximate it as a 200W equivalent halogen. I know the eye is logarithmic, i worked years as photographer when i was young.
Ok, CFL-Era is simply come to the end - now it's the time for LED's
Greetings,
Adrian