Thanks for the opinions guys. We have a lot of oil field castoffs that we use for fence posts, bale holders, anything you can imagine so reusing material was the idea. Think I might try a mock up and see what happens, I think the heat from where the pipes are welded together (hot spots) would cause more turbulance in the stream of air inside the insulated heat riser, we'll see, if nothing else I'll have some more fence posts. This J tube design reminds me so much of the pulse jet engines at the dawn of the jet age