Jay Angler wrote:
Allen Jackson wrote: This is intended (ideally) to facilitate growing more food locally without external inputs, and any BB that involved such could potentially benefit from that method if it's acceptable.
My understanding is that most hydroponics systems heavily rely on pumps, which rely on electricity. Fish in tanks can die pretty quickly if there's a bad electricity outage.
A system like Sepp Holzer's, was based on relatively small ponds, but the ponds were spring fed by gravity. Integrating fish raising with food production using traditional techniques from various places around the world, would likely also meet PEP standards.
When we first moved to our current location, the previous owners had built a two level pond with a higher level waterfall system. It took huge amounts of electricity to move that water from the lower pond to the top of the waterfall which was at most 6 ft elevation change. We gave up on it very quickly.
Readings I did over the years, convinced me that it takes a huge number of plants to balance a relatively small number of healthy fish. It's much less work for me to plant those plants in real dirt, than develop an aquaponics system and keep it balance and everyone happy.
I had the unique pleasure of encountering the original Growing Power urban farm outside of Milwaukee, Wisconsin early on. I went there several times & I brought others there, to see this wonderful concept in person. From the perspective of the typical urban dweller, this was mind-blowing that one could produce real food in such a confined space!
I attended several paid seminars and classes there to learn as much as possible about this concept because I wanted to move the needle on my retirement plans toward being much more self sufficient. I was fortunate to have made Will Allen's acquaintance and spoke with him about quite a few things. I initially caught his attention when I showed up to a paid seminar with a video camera, and he indicated that he didn't wish to have unauthorized video content published on social media about their operations. I told him that I don't even have or want to have social media accounts and none of my footage will ever show up on YouTube, etc., but I wanted to record what I did there, so I could more easily take notes, and also, so I could show my wife and friends what I'd found.
They were very big on aquaponics up there, but they weren't as advanced about solar power yet, and to be fair, solar power back then wasn't as advanced as it is today either. Yes, aquaponics does require a power input, and the more densely one is stocking their fish, the more power it requires to keep the system running.
At the low end of the scale, it can be done with little more than a bucket, used to water a planter box from a fish tank or small pond. No electricity needed there, and on the opposite end of the spectrum, it can grow to a huge commercial scale requiring many kilowatts of power to function. Backup power is a huge concern, the larger the system is, but one big takeaway I have, is a quote from Will Allen, saying "Don't think of aquaponics as a way to grow fish, but rather a better way to grow plants with less fertilizer" because most people are not going to be able to put in the inputs needed to produce large amounts of fish.
My recent experience with solar power and specifically with battery systems gives me the confidence I can build a power-resilient system to meet my own needs, even if it's outside of the scope that many would or could follow. Even if it's not allowed for BB here (yet?) I really agree with Paul's philosophy expressed in the thread about his permaculture scale. Even if I have to pioneer the concepts and demonstrate how well they work, before anyone else will get onboard with them.
Maybe no one else comes along with me, and maybe it's the start or new beginning of bringing more people to growing more of their own food, but either way, I'll be better off, being able to feed me & mine, so it's a win, for me, no matter what, as long as I get off the drawing board and DO.