Toilet paper...Everyone has a red line,boundaries that are different...Toilet paper is not something I'm going to do without. I'm also not going to do away with wearing factory made shoes just because they aren't natural or don't compost very well. As for washing a particular area with water and your fingers or a rag..I pass. There are few enough pleasures in life, they should not be ignored. Be it a setting sun or taking a dump the moment should be enjoyed to it's fullest..For me it should end with a wipe,,,I'll take the Charmin....