Hi John, Hardiboard does look very nice and is a durable siding. I'm sure I'm not the only person with a conventionally built home trying to transition as much as possible. Practically rebuilding a home isn't going to be possible for a whole lot of people. Trying to make the best decision within the limitations and options. The other consideration that I didn't mention is dirt. As I showed in the last photos, when I rebuilt the back of the house, prior to discovering permaculture, I had vinyl siding installed. Since then new tenants have moved into the rental property on the west (prevailing winds for me) side of me. They have destroyed the lawn in their entire backyard. It's a big yard and now only compacted dirt. On windy dry days it's like living in the dust bowl and it has coated the vinyl siding horribly. The siding has a slight texture and is difficult to clean. I'm stuck with it for now, but I know I don't want the rest of the house sided with it. I can't move and I can't afford to completely rebuild. As it is, I can only afford to do one side at a time. I'm still unsure what the best choice will be. I'll get some pricing for Hardiboard too. The really uncertain part is what will be discovered when the current materials are removed. lol. Renovations are always exciting and frightening at the same time.
As a side note, I have contacted the adjoining property owner and asked him to repair his back yard but he's done nothing. I even contacted the city about the excessive dust and water coming onto my property causing some minor erosion, in an effort to get that soil covered, but they won't do anything either. So, I plan on building a hugel-berm to catch and better distribute the extra water and get some shrubs and trees growing to filter the dust.