Yesterday I decided to purchase the $40 online "
Permaculture Design for Conserving Water" course available on the
Organic Life Guru website. There are a number of online courses available on the same site from recognizable names such as Toby Hemenway and Michael Pilarski and a few others. This seemed to me to be an endorsement of the content. The description of the course also includes a list of 13 "Lessons", and so for $40, it seemed like a value.
First, the term "Course" is in my opinion very generous in this case. The course consists of a recorded powerpoint-style presentation that Hemenway has given. The "lessons" (again, I think a very generous term), are the presentation broken down into segments, most of which are 2-5 minutes long. Two of the segments are free (the intro segment and a segment on "Contour Soil to Hold Water") one of which I think is one of the meatiest of all the segments. The majority of the remaining content can be gleaned from videos of Hemenway that are freely available online on Youtube or from his
book which retails for $17 on Amazon (Kindle price $9.88 ).
I am a fan of Hemenway, have paid for and read his book
Gaia's Garden, and try to consume as much content featuring him, including Paul's podcasts, as possible. I have to say that even for $40 I feel like a sucker for having paid for this online video "course". I suppose that for a certain group of the people, this collection of video snippets could prove informative. I realize that with this $40 I could be subsidizing an important part of the Permaculture movement, but if a person is paying for something, they should receive goods or services in return that aren't legally available online for free paired with a book from the same author for a fraction of that cost.
I'm truly disappointed in what I received for my money, almost to the point where I wonder if it is a scam and Hemenway even knows about the "course" being sold in his name. I certainly will not be paying for anymore of the videos available on
organiclifeguru.com. In comparison, I paid $25 for the digital download of
The Permaculture Orchard: Beyond Organic movie, which though is a slightly different subject matter, I feel is a far better value.
I do not have inexhaustible funds to dedicate to my Permaculture interests and education, and I set aside what I can afford for quality, interesting, and educational material. If you have been toying with the idea of paying the $40 for this online "course", sadly my suggestion is to spend your money elsewhere. I simply could not in good conscience recommend it to anyone.