Amazing how a month can pass by. I have been trying to research and better understand all of the conflicting information regarding the best way to insulate.
Here is what I am planning to do, I am interested in all critiques of my plan, so please continue with your appreciated advice:
Firstly I have installed the device to measure if radon is an issue in our situation.
I plan to remove all of the the existing insulation.
I would like to insulate the rim joists and the walls of the foundation in order to maintain a warmer climate in the crawl space. I am looking at 2 different approaches.
1 - use of a spray foam product to provide a complete air sealing and insulation in one application. I understand that there are environmental concerns with respect to these products, so I have some reservations about proceeding with this option. It is also expensive at about $3 / ft2 for a 2" application. Are there alternative products available that are more environmentally friendly? Are the energy savings worth the use of this product?
2 - Individually insulate the rim joists and walls with a rigid board product and substance to seal each are of the rim joists and seams. If I am going to go with this option, I need to identify the best product(s) for this application, so I am looking for recommendation to consider. In our local hardware stores they sell rigid rock wool based boards that could be used, which seem to be a better option to the typical foam products, but I am not sure that these are actually a more environmental option.
I saw a post that I am having trouble locating again, where there was a mehthod to insulate rim-joists with some type of board and a lime based (maybe hemp based?) product was used to complete the air sealing around the board. I also cannot remember what the "board" material was.
I am interested in opinions on both the most effective and economical options, so if there are other alternatives that I should be considering please let me know.
The recommendations in Canada also include insulation of the floor of the crawl space, but I am not planning to do it at this time but will evaluate how effective my first attempts at insulating are performing.
Hopefully these interventions will improve the comfort in the living room and prevent the pipes from freezing...I plan to monitor the temperature in this crawl space and will add space heating if required to prevent freezing.