William Bronson wrote: I think grain has the advantage when it comes to storage duration.
How many roots can be stored for years and still be edible?
This allows surplus to be built up, year over year.
This kind of surplus can equate to food security, but also translate into wealth, with all that comes with that.
I have read the potatoes can be dehyrated and powdered and stored indefinately. Haven't tried it myself, but probably will at some point. It appears here that as far as potatoes (and taro) go they are pretty resillient in ground here as far as rodents and other pests go. Same cannot be said for sweet potatoes, arracacha, yacon, oca and sunchokes. Nothing has had a crack at the Mashua yet.
The downer on potatoes is always disease, especially fungal pathogens. At least for virus this can be minimized by growing fertile plants (whether diploid or tetraploid) and there are individuals that do that thesedays. The Kenosha Potato project is one group with a seed train with lots of diversity and minimal cost.
Saying that I agree with Joseph Lofthouse on maize. As a staple that is easy enough to grow/harvest and then process and landraces with low nutrient requirements and drought tolerance can be found. I am working with perennial teosinte introgressing it into tough flour and flint lines with tight husks (from Shane Simonsens' parrot proof line) to prevent bird and rodent damage before harvest.
There is plenty of room for grains I think. But, when it's time to harvest it has to happen quickly and a all hands on deck sort of deal for that time. Shane Simonsens podcast Recombination Nation has an interesting interview with an Italian grain breeder Salvadore Ceccarelli. He has worked with lots of ancient grains reincoporating landrace genetics back into communities as staples. Worth a listen if grains are in your wheelhouse. Here are plans for a thresher that is worth looking at for anyone getting seriously into grains other than maize. Adaptable to many sorts of grains including legumes by changing screens and types of chain to beat the material. It sort of seems to be a community level piece of equipment that could run from electric or pedal powered if need. There are videos of it online for those that are interested.
Maybe Geoff has a point in the subtropics about grains. Plenty of variety for most/all of the year there. But if you have a proper winter its nice to have some options and even nicer to have variety.