To Anne Miller: We think alike. I did just that over the summer. Made calls everywhere, even stopped in the big box stores when they were along the way. It's like the product disappeared! And when I'd ask if they could order-- specifically the local agways and ace/true values, they had no listing in their systems. It's really weird.
To Debbie Ann: Your answer answered a related question for me. I had found a listing
online for "Arizona's Best" elemental sulfur-- exactly what you are describing. The website says it's not available, or out of stock in any stores basically east of the Mississippi. (Ironically or maybe not, it was in stock in several Arizona locations!) So I called my local store (it was either True Value or Tractor Supply) and gave the associate the upc or sku code for that product, ask her to order it, tell her I don't care how long it takes to come in, etc. She tells me that when she first typed it in, she saw a listing for something for "Arizona's Best" but it won't allow her to see any more info, and when she tried the code again, nothing came up at all. She tried an other way, then searched for sulfur, elemental sulfur, slow acting sulfur, anything I could think of that would link to the stuff I want. The only products that came up were the sulfates, like ammonium sulfate, the fast/short acting acidifiers. Weird, but consistent with my online searches... no elemental sulfur seems to be available for the northeast. Our soils here tend to be acidic to begin with, so I can understand it may not be a big seller. I can order a 50# bag (I think, or maybe 25#?) from 7 Springs Farm in Virginia (from the site Anne found), but the product is about $25 and the cheapest shipping is $30. I know the product is heavy, but I have a hard time forking over more in shipping than for the product. (Maybe I
should just tell myself the product is $55 with free shipping?!?) Anyway, that's why I thought ordering it through a local store would work, since they'd pay shipping... but so far, no go.
Thank you both for the replies, and although my search continues, it's reassuring to see that I'm not overlooking something obvious. Happy harvesting to you!