Of
course - if you have complete groundcover, and you don't let animals graze there, erosion will be quite slow.
I'm simply saying that a
swale is inferior to a Keyline, unless the piece of land that you have land is small and flat.
Keyline is designed to stop erosion by redirecting rainfall evenly across the landscape,
taking into account points of varying elevation - which swales can't.
To say anything beyond that is rather pointless, unless we get more details on the property in question.