I have just finished reading this book. I enjoyed it and would warmly recommend it.
A few random thoughts :
- The reader may be under the impression that the book is about practical solutions to the needs of everyday living: water
, food, shelter
, fuel, clothing, transportation… Instead, reading between the lines, I interpret it to be about societal and cultural integration: an entire society which works towards the same goal. (Not unlike bee or ant communities.) And this society is guided by a political class
which realizes that the absolute power that it wields is not something to be taken for granted – that in the event of an ecological catastrophe (e.g., one caused by deforestation, severe water shortage, or the collapse of the agricultural system) the whole society, including the rich and powerful, will be in mortal danger. Compare this with our present-day leaders, and draw your own conclusions…
- The book explicitly and implicitly highlights the importance of healthy cultural norms and values, reinforced - and enforced! - from the top down. The society described in the book is one in which restraint, simplicity, and modesty are seen as virtues, and practiced by everyone, regardless of wealth and social standing. On the other hand, greed
, luxury, and wastefulness are not only frowned upon, but outright punished. Greed is NOT good. Ability to afford luxury does NOT automatically give you the right to flaunt your wealth.
- Good management of natural resources requires societal cohesion, which in turn requires the subordination of the individual's aspirations to the community's greater goals. At the opposite pole you would have modern Western society, which tolerates (if not encourages) individualism, self-centredness, and the go-it-alone type of behavior - the same society that produced Ayn Rand ...
- On a few of occasions, the book contrasts the traditional, sustainable technologies in Edo-period Japan with modernized, Westernised present-day Japan. It does not even allude to the factors that triggered the switch from those time-tested, sustainable solutions that worked so well, to the modern, highly technological fixes which were known to cause a whole bunch of environmental and societal problems. I won’t go into these factors, but for those who are interested in the modern history of the region, I will suggest a few key words to search on Wikipedia: opening of Japan to Western trade, gunboat diplomacy, commodore Perry…