Glenn Herbert

Rocket Scientist
+ Follow
since Mar 04, 2013
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
Forum Moderator
Glenn Herbert currently moderates these forums:
Biography
Early education and work in architecture has given way to a diverse array of pottery, goldsmithing, and recently developing the family property as a venue for the New York Faerie Festival, while maintaining its natural beauty and function as private homestead.
For More
Upstate NY, zone 5
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
31
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Glenn Herbert

Two things: every offset adds drag, just like in a bench, and the chimney being nearly all in the warmer room gives better draft than if it is in the cold outdoors, and what heat it does lose goes to the room and not to the wind.
3 days ago
I understand your desire to eliminate roof penetrations, but I think the chimney routing is important enough to do a bulletproof overkill job of sealing the penetration to get a straight run up.
4 days ago
The barrel will get wood stove hot, and needs wood stove clearances and shielding from any combustibles. The part of the step nearest the barrel really needs to be masonry for safety.

Your bench will draft much easier, though that short run will not allow much heat extraction. It would work better to turn the bench into a hollow masonry bell, to allow gases to loiter and give up their heat.

Why do you insist on an exterior chimney for a brand new build that is still all on paper? An internal chimney will work better in all ways forever.
6 days ago
When I bought Matt's plans several years ago, you could get either the firebrick or the board version.
1 week ago
Cool idea, and can certainly be done, with some adjustments.

First off, your thought of a B-vent chimney exiting the wall requires a small system; I haven't seen larger than 4" or maybe 5" B-vent, and a system to heat the setup shown would need to be much larger, depending on your climate. If you just wanted to take the chill off where winter rarely freezes, it might work. You would need to prime the system with a fire at the bottom of the chimney to get draft started, or else the J-tube would most likely be very smokey until the whole system got hot. The best solution would be a chimney running straight up through the center of the house, so it starts warm and gives positive draft from the beginning.

A sinuous duct running as shown would, as mentioned, have a lot of bends which shorten the allowable run, and the steps could only be a few feet wide unless you have at least an 8" J-tube with 8" duct. Also, the amount of mass to enclose that winding duct path would take a long time to get warm, and the last part might never get very warm. A more effective arrangement would be a series of "bells", or stratification chambers. These are hollow masonry boxes, probably one per step, where the hot gases from the core fill the first box, cool a bit, fall to the bottom of the box, and go to the next box. There is next to no friction to this, so length of run is not a problem, only that the combustion core have enough power to warm all the bells.
1 week ago
I know you don't need any help, Peter My advice was to  the OP Richard. By the way, welcome to Permies, Richard.
1 week ago
Unless you want to hang out in your greenhouse for a couple hours or so a day, I think you would be better off with a batch box. Bigger wood capacity so fewer loadings each day.

A J-tube is much simpler and easier (and cheaper) to build for a first-timer, though. If laid out with conversion in mind, you can switch from a J to batch in a year or so when you have more experience. It all depends on your handiness, skills, and budget as to which way you should go.
1 week ago
I'm glad your climate is kinder to unprotected cob than mine is I suspected Montana might be more consistently cold in winter so there is less wet freeze-thaw stress, and dryer when warm so less rain erosion.
1 week ago
cob
Some barrels are solid, and some have a removable lid. You need one of the removable type to start with. These have an adjustable steel cupped band that holds the lid tight. There would be a watertight seal that would most likely need to be replaced with a noncombustible airtight seal.
1 week ago
For a straight wall, I would echo your concern. However, the sinuous form of the plan will keep it from tipping over. A dry-laid stone wall would still want some batter on a wider base, but the cob will hold itself together. What I am concerned about is the bare top of the cob. In a very dry area it might be okay, but with lots of freezing and snow, I would expect the surfaces to take some erosion damage by spring. Hopefully the builders know the local conditions well enough to be confident of its durability. I would have designed it to have a shingled type of rooftop to shed the majority of water.
1 week ago
cob