Kathleen Sanderson

pollinator
+ Follow
since Feb 28, 2009
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
For More
Zone 6b
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
6
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Kathleen Sanderson

Thekla McDaniels wrote:Kathleen
👍🏿.  I agree, but want to add one thing:  the quality of the animal protein depends on what the animal’s diet was.

I doubt that commercial feedlot operations in the USA that produce beef and chicken (and dairy) would provide adequate nutrition for a healthy human population.  Especially for young people growing the bodies that will determine their quality of life and health to last their whole lives, and old people like me whose digestive systems develop plenty of idiosyncrasies, and have greater nutritional needs.

Elaine Ingham did fascinating research in New Zealand on health of the soil determining health of the dairy herds that grazed the pastures on various soil health (diversity of soil food web).

I can’t remember right now the author, but “Soil, Grass, Cancer” published in the 50s makes the same connection between comparative health of populations eating food produced on various soils.



You are right - however. (LOL!) Yes, animal protein from animals that have been raised on good natural forage is *slightly* higher in quality and nutritional value. However, *any* animal protein from living animals (vs factory-produced 'meat') is still higher quality than plant-based foods.  If you can raise your own meat, or can afford to buy it from someone practicing regenerative agriculture, that's the best. But if you can only afford meat from the cheapest offerings at Walmart (which is what we are mostly eating right now), that is still a much healthier diet than plant-based. The best quality meat is from ruminants - but if all you can afford is cheap chicken and pork, that is still healthier than a plant-based diet. Anyone raising their own meat ought to be able to do better than the cheap stuff at the grocery stores (at least, better than the cheap pork and chicken, since even feed-lot beef will have spent most of their lives on pasture, while pigs and chickens are usually raised on grains and soy inside of buildings). The soil does make a difference; feed does make a difference. But there is no plant-based diet that is even close to equal to the nutrition of any meat-based diet. (Partly because many nutrients in plants are hard for humans to digest, and partly because nearly all foods from plants contain anti-nutrients which actively harm human health - some people are more sensitive to them than others, but they really aren't good for anyone.) In our diet, plant foods are condiments or seasonings, and our health has improved immensely. (Mostly autoimmune issues, some serious, as my daughter has lupus.)
5 days ago

Thekla McDaniels wrote:Would you be wanting a cash crop?

Saffron, if it fits your climate.

And, again if it doesn’t get too cold, a highly nutritious perennial, with great flavor as well, is moringa.

I think it’s worth considering that a limited diet is not just boring, but deprives our bodies of essential micronutrients and essential diversity.

I think we’re in the same situation as before we understood vitamins, and people were dying of pellagra, beriberi and scurvy.  They thought those were communicable diseases, until someone observed that only the poor were getting them.

I think if we have too restricted a diet, there can be deficiencies we just don’t know about yet, and the best defense is diversity!

Soon as I get my green house repaired from the damage of the summer of 2025 hailstorm, I will be trying to grow moringa.😊



It's possible to eat a very limited diet and thrive on it - if it's primarily animal protein. Plants need to be supplemented with animal proteins and fats for good health. But a widely varied diet is good for a couple of reasons. One is that if something fails, you are less likely to go hungry. And, as you mentioned, it can get boring to just eat the same few foods all the time. Although I will say that our mostly-meat diet really doesn't get boring.
5 days ago
World events are very troubling, but honestly, my biggest stress is in my own home - my handicapped youngest daughter (adult), who also has serious medical issues and is autistic and - when she's unhappy or not feeling good - screams, cries, and generally fusses like a toddler. Sometimes 24/7 for weeks (we are just starting to come out of one of those cycles, though she's still not completely out of it). Add to that, I'm not getting any younger (I'll be seventy next year), and have a bad back that has me just about crippled.

My response to both world issues and home stresses is the same - prayer, Bible reading, and remembering that God is in control. He has a plan both for the world and for our individual lives; we are in His hands; and we can trust Him completely. I still worry sometimes. I'm still very troubled by all that is going on the world - I can't imagine how scary it must be for people who don't know the Lord and aren't familiar with Bible prophecy. (And even scarier for people who do have some familiarity with prophecy, but haven't put their trust in God!) I still get tired and stressed with the care of my daughter, and frustrated by my own physical limitations. But I have Someone who I can turn it all over to - I keep going, one day at a time, with what is within my own sphere of responsibility, and let Him take care of the rest of it.

It's a daily thing. Sometimes hourly. We have small 'hope and trust' batteries, LOL! They need to be recharged frequently. But as long as I remember where my charger is, and use it, I don't run out completely.
2 weeks ago
I would also guess a weak spot in the shell. I've had eggs laid that had excess shell in a few spots, and wouldn't be surprised if the opposite happens sometimes. I really like 'boiling' eggs in the electric pressure cooker - even fresh from the hen house, they peel superbly once they've cooled down.
4 weeks ago
I'm kind of skimming through this (have major RL distractions going on at the moment, sigh), so I probably missed it, but if it wasn't already mentioned, elevation is extremely important, too. That's why Sunset Magazine developed a gardening guide specifically for the Western half of the US, because you can be in a southern latitude but gardening at such a high elevation that you can have frost in any month of the year.

Gardening guides for the North are interesting to me even though we now live in Kentucky, because I grew up in Alaska. Too old to want to go back now, but still have family there who can use information like this.
4 weeks ago
Dishes. It's not that I really even mind washing dishes (we don't have a dishwasher), it's that my back hurts when I stand. I can't stand for more than a couple of minutes before it's too painful and I  have to either walk or sit down. Also, I'm getting sick and tired of the kitchen sink drain being clogged up. My brother, who lives next door, spent two days trying to fix it a few months ago - successfully, eventually, but he had to crawl under the house and strap the long run of drain pipe up so it didn't have any sags in it. Now it's clogged again, and I'm considering just giving up and dumping all the liquids out the back door like our ancestors used to have to do. I hate having to ask my brother to help with it again. I'm thankful for my paid-for old house, but old-house plumbing (and wiring) is the pits.
4 weeks ago
Never. I have a livestock guardian dog (Anatolian Shepherd, weighs around a hundred pounds) in the pasture with the goats -she's only been on a leash once in her life (when I took her to the vet to be spayed), and I can't even keep a collar on her. She gets plenty of exercise out with the goats.

I also have three small dogs - twenty pounds or less - who have half an acre fenced around the house to run around in, and they do. They keep each other busy out there for a good chunk of the day. They do have collars on, but only the Rat Terrier has ever been on a leash. I wouldn't want to take them away from the house on walks, because then if they got loose, they would probably wander farther away from the house than they do now if they get loose (doesn't happen very often, but so far, they've never gone far).
1 month ago
Because my handicapped youngest daughter and I are mostly only eating meat (to deal with chronic severe health problems), I was curious. I'd heard people say, the carnivore diet isn't 'sustainable' because 'the whole world can't eat that way!' So I did some research. I don't have the figures in front of me (handicapped daughter took that notebook and ripped all the pages out of it just for something to do), but it would be possible to feed every human being on earth a diet of just animal proteins, combining all the land presently used for crop agriculture with all the land presently used as pasture. That wasn't even including forested land (much of which would benefit from being managed as silvopasture) or seafood, which is a plentiful source of animal proteins. Given that animal proteins are much better source of nutrients than any plants in existence, it seems to me that that would be a net benefit to the world! And there would still be room around the edges (and through the middles, if you grow food plants in the silvopastures) for plenty of fruits and vegetables. All you'd end up missing is the stuff that seems to not really be all that healthy for a lot of us anyway. (Also, I didn't figure in dairy products or eggs, just meat, at least two pounds per person per day. Add dairy and eggs to the total, and there is an abundance of nutritious food for everyone. And I was mostly looking at grazing livestock, not the ones that need row-cropped grains and legumes, like commercial chickens and pigs.) There is also a lot of potentially-usable land that isn't being fully or properly managed for grazing right now. Much of the far-north, for example - cattle and sheep can be raised clear up to Fairbanks and reindeer even further north. A good chunk of the land would need to be used for growing hay, but that's entirely possible. That land didn't get figured into my equations, either.

I know that wasn't what the original question was about - just something that I thought was really interesting.
1 month ago
My place used to be a small dairy farm, and had to be able to handle big trucks coming in and turning around. The areas for that purpose are graveled (heavily and deeply, to handle the trucks), but most of the time you can't see the gravel because of the grass growing through it. In one area, you can't see it at all, and in two other areas the grass is still a little thin and when freshly mown, the gravel is still visible. One of those grid systems could serve the same purpose; I don't know which costs more, is more easily found locally, or is made of more sustainable materials. Properly done, though, a gravel area lasts a long time, and it will allow grass and clover, etc., to grow up through it. We still have a big truck turning around here weekly (the garbage truck - we are at the end of a dead-end road), and it's been at least fifteen years since gravel was last added.
2 months ago

M Pearson wrote:This is one of the "issues" I have with the focus on gardening here :) Not that there's anything wrong with it, but my diet is quite beef heavy. I would have to raise a bunch of cows and grow maybe 5 tomato plants a year ;) All the gardening just doesn't really fit my lifestyle haha.



That's the same problem I have! We need a permaculture focused on livestock. Not that I don't love fruits and vegetables - I do. But I *feel* much better on a meat-based diet. So the plants need to be raised to feed animals. And for other purposes that plants are good for, like building materials, firewood, wind-breaks, beauty, wildlife diversity, fiber, and so on.

At going-on-seventy, and (even with the better diet) a bad back, I'm not going to be doing much, but the information should be there for younger people to make use of. Regenerative ranching and farming is a good beginning, but probably not the be-all and end-all of what can be done.  Silvopasture - using tree crops for shade, soil improvement (legumes fixing nitrogen), erosion control, shelter, and livestock feed - is another step in the right direction.
2 months ago