David Baillie

pollinator
+ Follow
since Jan 07, 2016
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
Biography
Builder, tinkered, gardener, charcoal gasification enthusiast, solar design, all things energy related.
For More
Central Ontario
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
0
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by David Baillie

David Baillie wrote:

John Weiland wrote:I'm hoping to piece-meal together a small system that would be expandable in the future for more off-grid power.  Initially, I was hoping to school myself by focusing on two essential items of the homestead-- the furnace (propane) for winter and the well pump for water.  As you might expect, non-winter months are not so crucial.  Even if the well becomes inoperative for a period, livestock watering can be done from the river near the house.  

I've already dabbled a bit with 12V-powered inverters for producing low-wattage 120V AC power.  What I'm envisioning for the current project is a 48V inverter/charger (Magnum Energy being one brand of interest) that would keep batteries topped up while grid-power is active, but be able to switch over to powering the furnace motor (120V) and well-pump (220V) if grid-power goes down.  A side angle here is the fact that I'm preparing to convert a 36V golf cart to 48V soon and this likely will involve several (3-4?....more?) 48V/30Ah LiFePO4 batteries.  Clearly one can get larger individual batteries, but I'm interested in keeping individual battery weight as low as possible so that they can be used in the golf cart (solar PV panel roof) in summer and shuttled easily to the basement for winter.

Questions arise around sizing the inverter/charger and battery bank for powering the furnace fan and the well-pump.  The furnace is less of an issue as it should be readily powered by an inverter of 4000-6000W (pure sine wave, peak surge watts nearly double the running watts). If memory serves me, the house well pump was ~2/3 - 3/4 hp submersible running at 220V and while the running amps/watts aren't terrible, the starting amps may be up in the 20s to low 30s.  So I'm more concerned about making sure the well pump won't trigger a system shut-down due to either batteries or inverter (or both) being under-sized.  A parallel string of 4 batteries each at 48V would yield 120Ah with internal BMS's sized for golf-cart amp surges (80 - 100A per battery...typically double that for short spike surges).  As finances allow, I would be integrating solar energy into the system as well as part of the expansion.  Input on this vision and design is most welcomed...  Thanks!

John the magnum is currently discontinued. If you want to stick to the older transformer based units like the magnum then a samlex or victron would do it for you. If you are going lithium choose an inverter meant for them like the lux or sol ark type. I am liking lux these days.


Well John, Michael is right about inrush current. If you are using a 3/4 Hp pump you will want to oversize the inverter. Older transformer units had better surge capability but they have not moved on to the new standards for meeting UL 9540 rules for using Lithium Batteries. In some areas of the world that does not matter. Here in Ontario I have to meet all the latest standards. So, Michael suggested the 6048 which is a good unit but you would want to substitute a 10kw all in one inverter as a subsitute if you wanted to go for the transformerless units. I would also invest in a 3/4 horsepower pump with a soft start like a grundfos pump.
Cheers,  David
1 week ago

John Weiland wrote:I'm hoping to piece-meal together a small system that would be expandable in the future for more off-grid power.  Initially, I was hoping to school myself by focusing on two essential items of the homestead-- the furnace (propane) for winter and the well pump for water.  As you might expect, non-winter months are not so crucial.  Even if the well becomes inoperative for a period, livestock watering can be done from the river near the house.  

I've already dabbled a bit with 12V-powered inverters for producing low-wattage 120V AC power.  What I'm envisioning for the current project is a 48V inverter/charger (Magnum Energy being one brand of interest) that would keep batteries topped up while grid-power is active, but be able to switch over to powering the furnace motor (120V) and well-pump (220V) if grid-power goes down.  A side angle here is the fact that I'm preparing to convert a 36V golf cart to 48V soon and this likely will involve several (3-4?....more?) 48V/30Ah LiFePO4 batteries.  Clearly one can get larger individual batteries, but I'm interested in keeping individual battery weight as low as possible so that they can be used in the golf cart (solar PV panel roof) in summer and shuttled easily to the basement for winter.

Questions arise around sizing the inverter/charger and battery bank for powering the furnace fan and the well-pump.  The furnace is less of an issue as it should be readily powered by an inverter of 4000-6000W (pure sine wave, peak surge watts nearly double the running watts). If memory serves me, the house well pump was ~2/3 - 3/4 hp submersible running at 220V and while the running amps/watts aren't terrible, the starting amps may be up in the 20s to low 30s.  So I'm more concerned about making sure the well pump won't trigger a system shut-down due to either batteries or inverter (or both) being under-sized.  A parallel string of 4 batteries each at 48V would yield 120Ah with internal BMS's sized for golf-cart amp surges (80 - 100A per battery...typically double that for short spike surges).  As finances allow, I would be integrating solar energy into the system as well as part of the expansion.  Input on this vision and design is most welcomed...  Thanks!

John the magnum is currently discontinued. If you want to stick to the older transformer based units like the magnum then a samlex or victron would do it for you. If you are going lithium choose an inverter meant for them like the lux or sol ark type. I am liking lux these days.
1 week ago

Aaron Yarbrough wrote:

David Baillie wrote: Lithium is a game changer as well as you can get full array production since they have low resistance to charging unlike lead and you don't waste time at the high voltage low amperage low production absorb stage. It has forced solar designers to change their ways as we now maximize panel numbers due to low panel costs as our first priority. On the down side you are usually best to repanel completely so you can maximize your strings and the all in one inverters are terrible at lead acid charging as they lack a proper 3 stage charging profile.



We woke up with no power a few weeks ago. One our 6V FLA batteries had a bad cell I think. Fortunately, I had recently received a lithium battery kit and was almost finished assembling it so we we didn't have to limp along for long. The difference between the FLA battery bank and the Lithium Phosphate one is amazing. We're still getting summer temperatures here(two months out from the winter solstice) and I'm running two mini splits, a convection oven, an induction cooktop two fridges and it seems like I can't run the battery out of power. Then with 2-3 hours of full sun it's back to 100% charge. I ordered more solar panels which I will still install but it definitely appears like the weak link of my system was my battery.

 

Yup, the use case for lead is shrinking all the time. It has proven to be a game changer for many people.
3 weeks ago

Sheldon Caulfield wrote:Hey all! I'm in a mad rush to install my new woodstove before the winter.

This is going in my unfinished basement, and you'll see in the attached photo that there are some soft mini split/heat pump tubes and cords strung across the top of the wall directly above the wood stove.

I'm having someone in for the final inspection in a weeks time so that I can safely burn, but it's $350 for the inspection so I really don't want to fial and have to book another one.

Does anyone think those tubes would be a problem? Additionally, are there any other glaring problems you guys can see around the stove that I'm blind to? (Except for the fact that the stove isn't hooked up to the chimney of course, lol)

Based on the wett inspections I've had done for clients everything looks good. Is the horizontal pipe leading to the chimney going to be double walled? If not you will want to double check your clearances to the Minisplit tubing. I assume your floor is concrete? If so you are good as you need 18" of non combustible floor in front of the stove.  Good luck on the Wett inspection.
CHeers,  David
1 month ago

Miikee Mike wrote:Hi folks. I was very confused by all those heavy electronics videos when i wanted to learn about Voc Isc and Bypass Diodes so i made a video that uses easy water analogies to explain it. It has a follow up video at the end screen going into reverse biased and forward biased Bypass Diodes and strings. They're just meant to get some ideas across. Feel free with feedback or questions.
YouTube

I've always liked the water analogy for explaining power to people. I usually use pressure for voltage, flow for amperage, and volume for watts... Its not perfect but it gets the point across to  people.
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

Crinstam Camp wrote:

David Baillie wrote: I would suggest then disconnecting the light circuits from the larger panel if possible and powering them using plugs.



Exactly how would one go about powering circuits from a separate inverter without disconnecting them from the main panel???

I'll let you look that up. I suggest you not do that with a portable floating neutral inverter for safety reasons.
1 month ago

Crinstam Camp wrote:

David Baillie wrote:I would suggest you look into low wattage LED bulbs then. The conversion efficiency on any inverter will be at its absolute worst in the first 20-30 watts. What are you lighting up? I've had good success with the USB based low wattage bulbs.  Your conversion efficiency will be much better stepping down in DC from 12 to 4.5 than stepping up from 12 volt to 120ac. Or any of the 12 volt led lighting out there. At the scale you are talking conversion will kill you. All that depends on your application of course.
Cheers,  David



I assume you meant to say low wattage DC bulbs?

Most of our lights are all double bulb fixtures with a 1 watt LED in one side and a pull switch socket with 2 Watt LED in the other. Just wandering through and turn on the switch and the 1 watt comes on, need more light? Pull the cord and the 2 watt comes on.

We aren't going to run new lines for DC lines to power the lights.

Our lights are all going to be on their own 12v bank of two 100Ahr batteries and 300 watts of panels. The little amount we will lose with a inverter is small, I just want it as small as possible lol

It started because we aren't supposed to hook 6 of our batteries in parallel for some reason that I'm still not clear on lol

I figured instead of just letting them sit here until we got two more we might as well use them.

But when I started thinking about it, I realized how much better it would be.

If the other bank drains, or the main inverter takes a dive, we're left in the dark. This way that doesn't happen.

Plus we have three 100 watt panels, that we were using as our main ones until we got the new 200 watt panels, that are now just sitting here along with the charge controller we had then. This way it all is still getting used.





Much clearer now. I would suggest then disconnecting the light circuits from the larger panel if possible and powering them using plugs. Your main house loads will be bonded neutral all small inverters are floating neutral and will usually overload or fry if plugged into a full house panel. In the case you describe any pure sine inverter will do efficiencies will all be about the same. Stick to pure sine though as lots of leds have fancy step down electronics in them that don't play nice with modified sine.
Cheers, David
1 month ago

Crinstam Camp wrote:

David Baillie wrote:

Crinstam Camp wrote:I'm looking for the most efficient 100 watt inverter (12vdc to 110vac) I can find.

Any suggestions?

Just generalities. Make sure its a pure sine wave inverter for efficient energy conversion and smooth running of your devices. Modified sine can heat up transformers and fry certain battery chargers on tools. I like the small wattage Victrons for durability; they have a 250 watt unit. Samlex is another good small inverter brand, renogy is so so, then you get into the take a chance ones on amazon.
Cheers,  David



All it will be powering are 1 and 2 watt LED bulbs up to a maximum of 40 watts in total. The normal would likely be closer to 6 to 10 watts

I would suggest you look into low wattage LED bulbs then. The conversion efficiency on any inverter will be at its absolute worst in the first 20-30 watts. What are you lighting up? I've had good success with the USB based low wattage bulbs.  Your conversion efficiency will be much better stepping down in DC from 12 to 4.5 than stepping up from 12 volt to 120ac. Or any of the 12 volt led lighting out there. At the scale you are talking conversion will kill you. All that depends on your application of course.
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

Crinstam Camp wrote:I'm looking for the most efficient 100 watt inverter (12vdc to 110vac) I can find.

Any suggestions?

Just generalities. Make sure its a pure sine wave inverter for efficient energy conversion and smooth running of your devices. Modified sine can heat up transformers and fry certain battery chargers on tools. I like the small wattage Victrons for durability; they have a 250 watt unit. Samlex is another good small inverter brand, renogy is so so, then you get into the take a chance ones on amazon.
Cheers,  David
1 month ago
Rico,
When I sit down with someone the first things I try to get them to articulate is what their goals are. So many people who do solar start with gear and build the picture around it. Usually those are the systems I visit to troubleshoot and rebuild. So what are your goals? With the property: size and intended use? What are the growth plans? how much care do you want to give the system?  Will a central power connection be involved? Would you feed back excess?  Will you be fully off grid? If so can you accept shortfalls in production or will a generator be required? Is it going to be a portable occasional generator or will it be an auto starting unit in case you are away for prolonged periods? Does gasoline work best for your area or propane or diesel? You are starting out in an area blessed with regular predictable sun with a large solar presence already which is nice. So before you ask for gear choices and advice you need to tell a story about what it looks like in your head. Keeping it all close to your chest results in poor advice. I enjoy Permies because by and large we are a very easy group to talk to and not much prone to judge. So tell me a story...
Cheers,  David Baillie
2 months ago