To start, I've not read all the contributions to the thread.
I've put this warning up in other threads, but am placing it here as well for all enquiring minds to have another opportunity for enrichment.
When planting any squash, it is important to know what sub tribe each variety is. Pepo is very commonly the summer squash. But there are winter/pumpkin types in the family. Pepo don't keep long. All pepo will readily cross with each other and saved seed will reflect that cross.
Maxima is the sub-tribe that grow the really big fruits. Dills Atlantic Giant is in this family. All maxima will cross pollinate with other maxima, and saved seed will reflect the cross.
Moschata is the sub-tribe that the longest keepers come from. I find them sweetest. Butternut are in this group. Moschata will cross, and the saved seed will reflect that.
There is another sub-tribe that I can't remember at the moment.
Only distance, and alot of it (often 100 feet or greater, up to a mile), will help prevent this crossing. Or only planting 1 of any sub-tribe. If I'm growing zucchini (green or yellow), I do not plant any pepo winter squash. I prefer the flavor and keeping qualities of the moschata, and currently have 1 fruit left from last October's harvest. I also like several in the maxima group, and I think the "cheese" are from this bunch.
I would add a link to Pearl's discussion with pictures of good eating winter squash, but I'm doing this from my old cell phone that has no further updates or support! Maybe after posting I will figure that out.
When I lived in Southern California, like zone 10 or higher, the squash only produced until short days arrived. They are annuals, and require replanting next year, or more plants this year for greater harvests. But then you need places and methods for keeping, whether it is canning, freezing, drying, or whole.
Here in West Virginia I've been keeping mine in the coldest part of the coldest room, checking and turning them monthly. And I'm down to my last, growing none this year. In favor of additional tomatoes and peppers which we eat more of.