Ned Harr

pollinator
+ Follow
since Jul 31, 2023
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
For More
Klumbis Oh Hah, Zone 6
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
20
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Ned Harr

R Grier wrote:Sorry, I missed your comment on that before then. Hubby is a bit more "Gung hoe" in some ways, he was prepared to live out of an RV/car trailer. I would if he decided to, I'd follow that man anywhere, but it seems to defeat the point to me. If we are raising the kids in a trailer the whole time they are growing up, then what is the point in a house in the end anyway? 🤔  Other than that, I think your answers are about all we could figure out too. Keep finding new ways to cut costs by using the land we rent, and keep finding new ways to try to establish passive income, for instance I'm thinking about going into children's book illustration. I have the art background, and I could do that from home while taking care of the kiddos. Hubby can't possibly work any more hours, but i could maybe multitask mine. We also bread the 3 hatchery chickens and 2 neighbor gift chickens we got last year into a flock 30+ of 10female:1male  in one year, and used every last scrap of the harvested birds. We are constantly looking for new ways, it's a real struggle though.


No worries, sometimes it's impossible to read every comment in a multipage thread.

I think it's good you are critically asking "what's the point". A lot of the stuff Fisker recommends, in my view, defeats "the point". And that's what I was getting at in the last couple paragraphs of my first comment on this thread: the point of life, of occupying time in the universe as a conscious entity, can't be just to defer all your joy and happiness for some imagined future where maybe you'll get it back. "Roughing it", and defying the conventional mainstream culture of consumerism and waste, is satisfying in its own right, but roughing it is also rough, and you can make your time needlessly unpleasant that way. Your time right now is worth something too, so while you should not just live purely in the present moment, you also have to guard the value of the present moment.
4 days ago

Glenn Herbert wrote:I understand your desire to eliminate roof penetrations, but I think the chimney routing is important enough to do a bulletproof overkill job of sealing the penetration to get a straight run up.


Thanks, I'll take that recommendation seriously. Can you help me understand why, though? Why is it so important to go straight up and not offset through a wall?
4 days ago

R Grier wrote:Ok... now how to do that with 5 young kids you homeschool (family of 7) and no land and current land prices vs wages...?  Any ideas? Because we are fresh out! đź« 


If you go up one comment and read what I wrote, you'll see that I thought consideration of kids was a weak spot in the book. Fisker admits he has no kids (or didn't when he wrote the book) and that his suggestions as far as kids go are more like guesses.

The good news for you is, he does recommend homeschooling. And more good news for you, if your kids are young then you still have time to indoctrinate them into the culture/lifestyle of frugality and stuff.

The other weak spot is whether or not your spouse is 100% on board and ready to go as hardcore as you are.

Fisker doesn't treat lack of land as an issue, in fact he might even see it as a liability, but I think he might suggest getting more creative with your living situation.

In any case, land and housing prices (dollar per unit of area) aren't the same everywhere so there's no such thing as "current land prices", and even within the same metro area or commuting zone--sometimes in the same neighborhood!--they can vary quite a lot. Also, how handy are you?

Same for wages: there isn't "current wages", there is a broad range of wages people these days earn. What could you do to make your income go up?
4 days ago
Thanks Coydon, those numbers are a huge help. I will tattoo them on my arm (figuratively speaking).

Coydon Wallham wrote:If you plan to be away from the house for extended periods during heating season and would need to warm it up from cold, take another 10' off or plan to prime the chimney before lighting the J tube.


I don't expect this will be the only way to heat the home. It might be, in which case I will take this into consideration, but my default assumption, until I learn I can get away with otherwise, is that I'll have to put in a mini-split or something to get insurance or a loan or a permit or some stupid reason like that. I'm also thinking about radiant floor heating.

An exhaust flue straight up would add another 10' back. Going through the wall it would need to go around the roof and above the ridge line or you will have smoke blown back in under certain wind conditions, or if upper level windows are opened.


Yup, that makes sense. In my illustration I didn't articulate what the roof is like, but that wall ends just above where the duct penetrates it, and there is no floor above. Just the raked end of the roof. There are no windows on that side of the house either.

The mass should not contact any wood, it requires masonry heater clearance, which is 4" by the codes I've heard of. Also, the feed tube is likely to throw sparks or even burning wood if fed too long of a piece. Some people treat it like a hearth, but others get away with less clearances there...


Got it. I will make adjustments.
5 days ago

Thekla McDaniels wrote:There are formulas for how many feet of stovepipe and how many 90 degree bends your rocket can “push”.

Sorry I can’t quote them.  Just thought I’d mention it because you didn’t yet know about including a bypass.

Also, you’ll be glad if you design in a cleanout or two in strategic locations.

Good luck.


Thanks for mentioning that.

Other commenters had informed me about the bypass, and I included cleanouts in my design from the beginning (they are pointed out as #3 in the illustration in the OP).

I will look up the formulas and spec the size of the exhaust run probably after I have acquired my big/important/expensive components, but it will be good to at least have that information ready. What do you think is the single best and easiest to use resource for that?
5 days ago

Jay Angler wrote:

Ned Harr wrote:  Many of them already have dirt or gravel driveways, small outbuildings, and the houses themselves could, at minimum, be slept in or used for storage while I built the house I want. A few of them even have utilities present.


Good roads cost a lot of money - even a dirt road will have had a bunch of "compaction" done for you. I have upgraded our gravel road with hand tools as needed, and it was a pile of work, but there's no way I could have done so starting from scratch.

Similarly, even if just equipped as "guest accommodation" or "storage outbuildings", existing buildings that can be upgraded or dismantled for parts, representing value when you look at the cost of materials these days.

The land itself can be upgraded with hugels, Goat recyclers,  mobile chicken coops etc to improve fertility.

What you can't change is: A) access to Hospitals etc. B) toxic neighbors whose activities will run-off onto your land in storms (although ditches and certain plants can help) C) Flooding - just look at the places that have flooded in the last 2 months/ 2 years/ geologic time, and determine the risk for where you're looking.

Sometimes you have to accept less than perfect, so long as enough of your boxes are checked! One of permaculture's premises is taking less than perfect and turning it into paradise!


I like to think of it less as "accepting less than perfect" and more like does it meet the minimum requirements, and if it does, what else is thrown in on top as a bonus. My minimum requirements are kept low enough to be a wide net so that the bonuses can be used to narrow down the contenders.

For example, my minimum requirements for a parcel of land might be that it's within a certain distance from groceries/hardware store/hospital, covers at least 3 acres, has elevation changes but with at least one buildable site, and has mature trees. If I used only those requirements, then Zillow would show me dozens of properties that are well within my budget, even factoring for eventual future costs.

Then I could use the bonuses to cull the herd: which property has an already compacted dirt driveway? a scenic view of a mountain or other picturesque landform? an existing shed or trailer? a half-dug pit for a septic system? a particularly awesome neighbor I met when I visited? etc.

For as long as I can remember, I have always looked at what others call junk and seen hidden treasure. The nightmare that the previous owner wanted to get away from could be the foundation of my dream. It's as true for whole houses as it is for bits of wood or metal (though I've reined in my pack-rat habits quite a lot).

That's how I see it, how I've seen it for a long time, and as a result I don't feel like I've had to compromise much to live in near-constant paradise.
5 days ago
PS. Maybe relevant: this rocket mass heater is positioned in a way so that during the summer it (and the earthen floor in front of it) will be in full shade all day, acting as a heat sink, while acting as a thermal mass in winter, absorbing solar gain through south-facing windows, so that on sunny days at least, it becomes warm and even radiates warmth later without a fire ever burning in it.
6 days ago
Okay, here is another redesign:



This one kind of splits the difference. The mass comprises the lowest two tiers. The upper two tiers would probably be built as abutting it all the way to the lower level floor, rather than sitting on top of it (as I accidentally depicted).

The exhaust duct has one 180-turn in it, then it continues to rise horizontally until it turns upward to exit via the chimney.

Most of the chimney is inside the house but it does turn to exit through the wall because I don't want penetrations in the roof. In the image, that turn is depicted as a hard 90Ëš because I am not slick enough with Sketchup to make it look otherwise, but in reality this could be more of a sweep, or even two 45Ëš turns, or whatever.

Everywhere the mass is in contact with wood, it should get no hotter than "warm" right?

I haven't provided exact measurements because I don't have any; I was thinking there would be about 70" of elevation difference from finished floor to finished floor, with a 2-foot height difference between tiers, but the horizontal distance--the width--of this space is totally arbitrary. I think I set it to about 16' for the model because that felt right, but it could be as little as 10' or as much as 25'. I thought 16' from exterior wall to far edge of stairs seemed reasonable. I understand there are spec'ed lengths for rocket mass heaters or their components, so I would be open to adjusting the width based on that.

I still am not clear on the idea of stratification chambers.
6 days ago

Riona Abhainn wrote:The advantage to a phased plan like this is that you can save up chunks of money and do each thing, land, utilities, house, etc. each time you save enough money up for it.  Obviously land with a finished house is more spendy than land without one so this makes sense.


Lately in my Zillow searches I have been seeing a few small run-down or half-finished houses on 5+ acre parcels, in the area I am targeting, and they are not going for much more than comparably sized raw land.

Many of them already have dirt or gravel driveways, small outbuildings, and the houses themselves could, at minimum, be slept in or used for storage while I built the house I want. A few of them even have utilities present.

So, I have added properties like that as a possibility in my mind.
6 days ago
I did a redesign based on the concerns I heard here, which chiefly stemmed from the size of the thing and the length and number of turns in the flue.

1. I simplified the design immensely; now it's a conventional-looking rocket mass heater. The exhaust flue is a straight shot, and the "mass" is only what I painted orange in the model. (I did beef up the mass slightly around the bell.)
2. The stairs and the rest of the wall are framed conventionally, with wood. I have depicted them as simply wood, but they could be clad with something.
3. My new question is partly about that cladding:

Do I need something special where the rocket mass heater meets the wood-framed walls? A required wall-covering? An air gap? Some kind of masonry?

I know how they do this with conventional fireplaces, but the mass part of a rocket mass heater does not get as hot as the outside of a conventional fireplace's firebox or chimney.

PS. I don't feel like going through the rigamarole again with Imgur, but I'm going to also modify this so there's a cut-away in the terrace wall behind the bell, to keep that part of the wall further from the bell.

1 week ago