It probably would and in fact most apple trees that will grow in my neck the woods are grafted onto "Siberian crab" not the other way around. I want to start some for the purpose of providing a cross pollinator for the one at the farm which had lovely blossoms this year but not one dang apple and for grafting other cuttings to so they will live more than one year here. Most of the nurseries here in fact sell stuff that is not suitable for our climate, and soon dies, usually after a year or two at most.
I will persist in trying. I can start seeds from every dang apple that I buy from the store but not the one that grows in my back yard. ARGH!
Ill try somemore cuttings in the spring I guess. maybe when I rake up this falls piles ill just dump the whole lot all over the farm, some here, some there who knows.