John Polk wrote:
You may get more resistant seed, and you may get weakened seed. My suggestion would be to save some seed, and to buy some fresh seed. Plant both next year (in separate areas), and then save seeds from whichever plot does best.
Correct... sort of. According to Mendelian genetic theory, you would be 100% correct.
But that has not been my experience, nor has it been the experience of the majority of old-fashioned plant breeders. It appears as though Mendel did not have everything quite completely under control when it comes to pathogen resistance. It does work for some traits, it's true... but traits which do NOT necessarily translate to survivability, such as coloration or flavor.
My bet... and yes, I would bet money... is that saving this seed and planting next year would show a noticeable reduction in pathological harm. I am
that confident!
What do you say? Small wager?
