posted 5 years ago
Gillian, yes, that would probably work, but expect flies, gnats, rodents, and varying amounts of time of decomposition depending on the season. And is the pile of ...well, let's be frank....*%^&.... is where rodents, flies, gnats, etc., have access to it, that is never a good idea because the stuff gets tracked around by the animals. And who wants to shovel the contents year after year even if it is composted. It's only fascinating for about the first 6 months. Then reality sets in, and not everyone feels comfortable with that. Outhouses are cold, out in the dark/storm/rain/snow/icy ground, and do you want everyone, including maybe a small child (even if it is a guest) going out into the dark of night?
Also, at some point someone will get nauseous and will need to have a clean and sanitary place to go in a hurry! Only having a composting toilet/outhouse doesn't really allow for that.
After years and years of composting toilet use, I've switched to a worm tank. You could use this witihout a flushing toilet, if you aren't there yet. Worms are amazing, and very quickly deal with the contents as long as it's damp. Worms can drown, freeze or bake in too much heat, so the tank (which doesn't have to be much more than 50 gallons for 2 people), needs to be in a protected place. The tank that I've had working for about a year never has an insect near it, maybe a few ants at first, but that's it. No bad smell. I've never had such a success after having used composting toilets for 20+ years.
We've got enough to deal with living remotely, so the more comfortable, easy, and warm the bathroom can be, the happier everyone is.
Search these forums for worms and composting toilet, humanure, there are diagrams and photos.
Mediterranean climate, hugel trenches, fabulous clay soil high in nutrients, self-watering containers with hugel layers, keyhole composting with low hugel raised beds, thick Back to Eden Wood chips mulch (distinguished from Bark chips), using as many native plants as possible....all drought tolerant.