Coprinus lagopus?
If it dissolves into a pile of black goo in a few more hours, that would clinch the ID.
Inedible and poisonous are two different things. If you sterilize media that had inedible mushrooms and then grow a flush of edible ones, that's probably going to be safe (no uptake of toxins). However, if there are
Amanitas growing on something, I'd rather not experiment in reuse of the media.