Erin, you are in Lander? Do you know my uncle Ralph Allen? His family (now 3 generations) have lived there for as long as I can remember.
I agree that a lot of the "math" doesn't add up. That doesn't mean that it is unfeasible, however. Earthships simply must be built fairly large to be self-sufficient, and they will never be self-sufficient for food, something any builder of an Earthship must understand. 3200 square feet of roof may sound big, but how big is that really? Let's do some quick numbers.
The living space inside the Earthship is only a part of the roof. Let's say a family of four needs a conservative 1500 square feet of living area. This could be 75 feet wide by 20 feet deep. Now using the recommended form factor for the
greenhouse, you would need an additional 10 feet of
greenhouse in front of your living area. Now the cisterns. After accounting for the depth of the cisterns, the insulation and berming, and if you were to put the "drain" into the cistern as far back as possible, (not forgetting that the Global design cisterns are too small and will need to be amped up), you have about another 10 feet of roof space.
Adding an overhang of 2 feet, a slope of 7 degrees, and you now have a roof area of 3173 square feet. It is feasible, you just have to eek out every square foot of your roof that you can. Now, if you live in a rainy area, it is easier.