I am newly registered to the forums here because you all seem to be the most experienced and helpful people I have found on the net for wood stove/heater design an experimentation. I have the Rocket Mass Heaters book now, I have read a tremendous amount of information on this site, and I have looked all over the web to gather more information. I am a technical person, I have a good understanding of thermodynamics and fluid dynamics, and am good with my hands in metal and masonry construction. So, I am capable of understanding the physics of why rocket heaters work... and I love the idea.
I have a 30' x 40' steel building with two 10' tall roll up doors on one of the long sides, and a standard 3' door on one of the short sides. the ceiling height is 11' at the edges and 14' in the center. 3' from the middle of the back wall, opposite the roll up doors, I have a 6" ID triple insulated chimney pipe with code approved spark arrester already through the roof that hangs down 2' from the ceiling with nothing attached at the moment. There was a barrel stove in the shop at one point with the previous owner, he took it with him. I use this shop for a variety of things. I have long term household storage on industrial metal racks along one of the short walls, I have woodworking tools, lawn care equipment, storage for work materials (wiring, conduit, etc), and three motorcycles. I still have plenty of room to work on projects in here as well as doing vehicle maintenance. One of my projects will soon be to pull in my 22' car trailer to rebuild it.... there is plenty of room. I have even held poker games in the shop with my work van and three motorcycles still inside.
The problem I have is that in the winter, I just can't work in there. It is too cold for my aching and aging joints. We do not get long cold winters like many of you do elsewhere in the world... but it is too cold for me. I had a single barrel stove in a shop before that was almost this size, but with a lower ceiling and it did warm the room some and gave me a place to get closer to warm myself through radiation. I was all set to buy a kit and put one together and then started researching other options. I know I can get a double barrel kit to add another barrel on top for more heat transfer, and use a fan to try to draft more air off for better transfer. But my desire would be to burn cleaner and hotter, which in theory makes more heat available to transfer out to me and the room. I also have a strong desire to be able to have a system that can run with no power input other than feeding it wood. I have seen on this site many people trying to do some rather wacky stuff that the rocket heaters just won't like to run with, and I have seen you guys try hard to help people get back on track.... but I have also seen a high resistance to some things that have not been done before. I am not looking to heat a living space long term. I am not looking to make something to sleep on, or lounge on so contact or conductive heating is not what I am looking for unless it is to conduct through a heat sink to give more surface area. I want to pump heat as quickly as possible out into the air and objects in the room through radiation and convection.
With all that lead in out of the way, you know what i have and what I am trying to work with here.
Option one is a double stack barrel stove....
we all here know the simplicity of this and the draw backs to this design. I have seen one (see video link below) where there were pipes cut through the top barrel to add exposed surface area for more heat transfer, and I have also seen one where a triple stack was made. If no other options will work, this will be my fall back....
Double barrel with extra pipes
http://youtu.be/wzQdj2TZfsI
Option two is a 55 gal pocket rocket design.
I would want to get more heat transfer off of the exhaust if possible though, so I would be looking at trying to pipe it into a secondary barrel as well to increase the exposed surface area for heat transfer. I could possibly incorporate the barrel with the extra piping like was seen in the video for the double stack stove to get even more surface area.
Option three is a "J" rocket stove design that does not use a mass, but radiating chambers. One of my Ideas to help with this actually seems to be something that could fit quite well in and rocket design. Below is a sketch up of the desgin basics of this modification. The other standard attributes of a rocket stove.... including height of riser vs. the length of tube, etc would be adhered to. If I need more height, I can add another set or partials of barrels for the riser and bell.... I just drew it with one barrel height to get the point across. The point of this is to have 55 gal barrel number two be a large manifold for the exhaust gasses to fall in, like the ones you guys are normally sculpting... to allow very easy access for clean out... and to be able to use it for more radiant and convection heating. As the drawing shows, I could take me pipe out to another barrel or to the chimney from there. I might also be able to pipe horizontally out of the manifold instead of vertical to go to another barrel, much like the way you guys pipe horizontally to go into your mass.
So... now I wait for your thoughts, ideas, and suggestions. I know it is not a Rocket Mass Heater, I dont want the mass. But this is the wood stoves section, and we should all be about burning as clean as possible no matter how we capture the heat from there. So, lay it on me.