I heard my favorite boots gently weeping from the corner today. I’ve been using Otter Wax (
https://www.otterwax.com/) leather care kit for many moons now (good quality stuff goes a long way) — although now I’m familiar enough with the ingredients and though-process of each step, and have the materials sitting around to make it myself when this runs out. Halfway through the job, I wondered what permies.com might say on this subject. I’ll be darned if there’s not a PEP BB for every thing!
My boots are leather outer, leather-lined, rubber sole and stacked leather heel. I’m in a suburban environment, so these are a mix between dress boots and daily travelers. Occasionally do a buff/shine if going out somewhere nice. Once every couple months I go all out (as pictured for this PEP) with:
1. Soap (beeswax + castile)
2. Salve (carnuba + shea butter)
3. Oil (safflower + vitamin E)
4. Wax (beexwax + lanolin)
Step 1: Get Your Torch! (And Soap Box?)
Saddle Soap. Apparently there’s controversy (say it isn’t so!) over this stuff. The kind I have isn’t
ye olde version — just castile + beeswax — so I have no qualms using it on my favorite pair of kicks. Calls for ‘stiff brush’ — I use an old toothbrush and it works just fine. Soap it up, then wipe it down with clean cloth.
A couple articles on the sordid history of saddle soap:
Section of interest is ~2/3 way down the page: http://www.usmilitaryknives.com/leather_care.htm
This one talks about pH, which I found interesting: https://bootmoodfoot.com/saddle-soap-leather-boots/
P.S. I do love the wikiHow link in the original post about using a banana to clean!
Step 2: Condition(al) Love
From the kit’s insert:
“leather is happy when it’s hydrated.” Start with soft cloth for large areas; fingertips for difficult-to-reach spots. Leave for 30 minutes; buff with clean cloth.
Step 3: Shine On!
Polish. Soft cloth to apply, even coating, work it into the leather with hands. Can use this version on rubber/leather soles ... and my hands benefit, too!
Step 4: Sally seals sea shells...
... Or something like that.
Beeswax + lanolin waterproofing step. Soft cloth, evenly coat, use fingers or soft brush to work it in everywhere, especially places more susceptible to water damage. Let it sit overnight before use. Test by splashing water on it — if beads up and rolls off, good to go!