As an Animist/Pagan/Screaming Lefty, I've found it somewhat difficult to find like-minded community in a extremely conservative rural area, at least that doesn't require a LOT of driving. I get along with all my near neighbors and some of them I consider good friends, but we NEVER talk
politics or religion. EVER. They probably assume I'm a Christian. They probably know I'm not Republican because my husband has worked as the alternate election judge at the
local polling place and we've had non-Republican candidate signs on our place a couple times. The fact that we are a heterosexual couple probably helps us blend in.
Personally, and this is just my own experience, there's no particular reason one can't get along with the neighbors even if one is very different from them philosophically. BUT, in my case I am not flamboyantly different looking, dressing, or acting. My hair is slightly weird but not as noticeable as a mohawk. I tend to wear home-made but not very weird clothing. Though I host Pagan/Animist/Freethinker gatherings at my place, I don't put up big signs or have lots of drumming, etc. The neighbors have much louder parties than we do.
My main bit of advice is - be yourself, but don't flounce. Don't talk politics or religion with the neighbors, ever. Don't wear your biggest pentacle to the grocery store. Find something in common with the neighbors, like say,
gardening, bird-watching, hunting. My husband fixed up an old 1965 Datsun pickup truck which is the smallest pickup truck in the county and always an icebreaker and social lubricant wherever he goes. Anything to do with trucks or tractors will help you get along in the country! Walking the dog on our one-lane road is also how we meet and chat with the neighbors.
Here are some links that might help:
http://www.rainbowlaw.org/html/directoryWV.htm http://gaywestvirginia.com/ http://www.paganspace.net/group/wvpagans http://www.paganshire.com/West-Virginia-pagan-stores.aspx http://www.witchvox.com/vn/hm/uswv.html http://uucharlestonwv.org/