Something that confused me for a while while studying permaculture were the principles. The various lists are not all the same. So I made a table that shows a comparison of the most common principles
<tbody>
David Holmgren: Permaculture: Principles and Pathways beyond Sustainability |
Bill Mollison: Permaculture, a Designers' Manual |
Mollison: Introduction to Permaculture |
Toby Hemenway: Gaia's Garden |
1. Observe and interact |
|
1. Relative location. |
1. Observe |
2. Catch and store energy |
|
4. Efficient energy planning: zone, sector and slope |
3. Catch and Store Energy and materials |
3. Obtain a yield |
|
|
12. Get a yield |
4. Apply self-regulation and accept feedback |
|
|
14. Mistakes are tools for learning |
5. Use and value renewable resources and services |
Work with nature rather than against |
5. Using biological resources. |
10. Use biological and renewable resources |
6. Produce no waste |
|
6. Cycling of energy, nutrients, resources. |
|
7. Design from patterns to details |
|
8. Accelerating succession and evolution. |
9. Collaborate with succession |
8. Integrate rather than segregate |
Everything gardens |
2. Each element performs many functions. |
4. Each element performs multiple function |
9. Use small and slow solutions |
|
7. Small-scale intensive systems; including plant stacking and time stacking. |
7. Use Small scale intensive systems |
10. Use and value diversity |
|
9. Diversity; including guilds. |
|
11. Use edges and value the marginal |
|
10. Edge effects. |
8. Optimize edge |
12. Creatively use and respond to change |
The yield of a system is theoretically unlimited |
12. Permaculture is information and imagination-intensive |
13. The biggest limit to abundance is creativity |
|
|
|
2. Connect |
|
The problem is the solution |
|
11. Turn problems into solutions |
|
|
3. Each important function is supported by many elements. |
5. Each function is supported by multiple elements |
|
Make the least change for the greatest possible effect. |
11. Everything works both ways |
6. Make the least change for the greatest effect |
</tbody>
*Tired to see if this was talked about elsewhere, and couldn't find it. If anyone does know if it was, let me know.