Scott Weinberg

+ Follow
since Dec 24, 2016
Merit badge: bb list bbv list
For More
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
In last 30 days
1
Forums and Threads

Recent posts by Scott Weinberg

if you have this disease, (building airplanes) and keeping up places to land,   All other projects take second place or are far below.    
19 hours ago

thomas rubino wrote:Hey Ben;
As Glenn said, you would want a removable top barrel.
They usually have a plastic seal under the lid that you want to remove.
I have found that, with rocket use, you do not need to reseal the lid; it is cupped, and the band tightens it enough that I have never had a leak.
For setting the barrel on a masonry base. You can put cob down and seat the barrel on it, or I prefer to use a Superwool gasket apx 1/2" thick.



As has been stated - there are two types of barrels that seem to be world wide. Barrels with removable lids that have two bungs and a bolt tighted clamp and solid topped barrels with two bungs only.  Toss in heavy and light barrels, that still gives you only about 4 choices.   Open top barrels will be your friend.

Most industrial areas have users of both.

Almost always, if you want to stack barrels, the top of one barrel matches up to the bottom of the other barrel and the clamp that came with the open top barrels will clamp the two together. Often air tight.

Thus only the fire box end would need to be cut out. ( a simple process ) Even a hammer and sharp steel chisle will do it.

Best of success!
1 week ago

Peter Chauffeur wrote:Hello Scott!

Thank you for correcting my research info. It’s ironic that there are so many different units for measuring energy output!  



Peter Chauffeur



Actually with reading all the things your trying to do,  using  BTU's  produced  is exactly what is the most commoningly used standard the world wide. All other units of energy are far less common

Working with your pellets, oil, orange peels, and all the other things your trying, rating what you put in vs what you get out in BTU's would be the best standard and understood method of calculating effciency of your unit.

Just remember some of the more famous experimenting words-  "If you don't know where you been, how do you know where your going?"  i.e. Recordings of your progress count much!

Best of success.
1 week ago

Peter Chauffeur wrote:Hello Fellow Permies and Rocket Mass Heater enthusiasts!

. Hardwood pellets advertise around 7,000 BTUh/lb and waste auto oil is 140,000 BTUh/lb. That’s a 20 fold difference in energy. So to get a little more heat out of our wood pellets we only need to let a half quart or 500 ml of oil to soak into a 40 lb bag pound of wood pellets! I’ll keep you all posted on that.


Peter Chauffeur
Be Safe, Be Warm and Be Kind



Waste oil can be considered 140,000 btu per gal, not pound. So 18,500 or so per pound.  So this may effect your formula or expectations to some degree.
1 week ago
I will reiterate my experince on IFB's.  I have  completely removed all, and not one was worth using again (anywhere) They were all used in the riser of a 7" sized batch rocket. I have to admit, I run it hard, but that is not the concern. Until someone we can trust, says- these (brand name and type of IFB's) have held up for 5 years running with narry a problem.  I will not use.

Likewise, on formed fireclay only, or even thin cast refactory. There are folks here with experince that caution the use.  While I no longer have photos, I can show where rather thick ceramic was heated far to quickly and locally on a large piece area, and then shattered. (costly to)

AS was stated, if you don't build your stove to easily get to it inside the bell, the work following that probably will be required is high. This can be delt with ( showed in my build) and yes it worked. As I am rebuilding without touching the bell.

A little fore-planning like your doing will pay great dividends I believe.

Best of success.
Scott
3 weeks ago

Eric Rothoff wrote:Three things have held me back. The first is just making the time because of the other problems.


Yes, they do take commitment to get 'er done.
 

Eric Rothoff wrote:
The second is Insurance.  Even if I was to get the Rocket mass heater certified as a wood stove, it would cost at least an extra $150 dollars a year, and severely limit  insurance companies that I could use.


While this has been discussed in the past, this is something to be considered, but I presume you have a house with NO pre exhisting chimney? NO one has said this is for everyone, I think of this forum (and subject matter) as more of a "if you want to build, this is how it has worked, and please toss out your planned ideas" to others that have successfully made it work.

Eric Rothoff wrote: The third is the main reason. I have a split level home with water heat.  The normal air heating, pebble or cob stoves that just radiate heat would not work well. I might even be able to remodel my fireplace  into a rocket stove, but it would only heat one of the four floors.


Yep, sometimes the  layout is simply not right for the stove. Again it may not be for everyone.

Eric Rothoff wrote: What I need is a plan Rocket mass heater that heats water, (yea, probably pressurized as we don't want to to "Boom Squish" I would probably do a batch rocket heater ask I would not want to constantly feel the heater as I believe you have to do with the J tube heaters.  What I would want to do is heat the water for the day or two usage  when the weather is mild and more often when it gets colder.


I read this to mean you think a pressurised system is safer and more likely to NOT have "boom squish" effects?  Please explain?  As far as heating water and making use of that warm water as a mass storage. It would seem that on this forum, if there is a will, there is a way.  It works both ways. to be sure.
3 weeks ago

Scott Weinberg wrote:

Robert Ray wrote:The final heating elements (PTC) were delivered today. So I will begin this weekend on the assembly.



 Maybe not cut and dried, but it seems like there should be a "yes it worked" or
" no, it didn't work"  or a comment on where it is going from here.

Am interested.



Robert, with this fairly new thread started  " Good physical "solar sinks" for excess PV power?"  I thought by now, you may have come up with a conclusion for your experiment and it may go with the new forum thread just listed., Please comment here or both.

thank you
Scott
1 month ago

Mike Oswaldrosnick wrote:I had similar questions about durability, but running a cleaner fuel helped a lot. I use kiln-dried wood from https://onestopfuel.ie/ and haven’t had cracking issues since switching. Consistent moisture content seems to make the burn easier on the bricks and metal parts.



Mike, I was wondering how you determined this boughten fuel has worked better for you.   What were you burning before? And if you had cracking issues, did you replace those particular bricks?

In general, wetter wood, would have a cooler burn with the moisture converted to steam. Or were you thinking this "steam" was the problem?

Just curious.

Scott
1 month ago
The Purpose of a Rocket Mass Stove in my opinion.

A simple review:

Just like everything in life, it (A Rocket Mass Stove)   is not and cannot be everything to everyone.  What it is, when built to the numbers, a extremely viaable wood burning-enviromentaly sound-and quite simply a very stable and consistent heat source.

If you want to go out and look for all the reasons that it won't work you will find them. If you convince yourself you do not have the ability to build it, you will not beable to.  Such is life for some.  Mr. Can't, never did anything, and speaking to your self, "I can't do this, and I can't do that, will simply enforce your ability to not get it done, you won't"   The desire to build is something you either have or don't have.  It can be developed and nurtured with sound advice. Much of that advice is here on the forum.

Can a person develop the skills, learn a trade good enough, find new friends along the way, and end up with a soul warming, house warming endevor?  Absolutely I have friends on this forum site, I will probably never meet, but enjoy them imensely.  .

Can you drop everything, and build over the next 30 days, sure, but you don't have to. There have been many winter projects, started at the beginning of fall and finnished before spring. Nothing wrong with that.

I am off my stump, carry on good folks!

Scott
1 month ago
As this is rather old ( 3 years) Please don't be shy, how has this worked out for you.  

So many threads start out  " this is what I am going to do and it is going to save this X amount"  and then we never hear from again.  So, where does this "great idea" fall into?

cheers
Scott

ps  I am a equal progress comment oriented Person!  Simply meaning, if it is a great idea and has worked out well, then all want to know, and if it didn't work out, that should be stated as well. Learning from dreams of others good or bad, is the basis of true learning.
1 month ago