posted 5 years ago
Andy, are you thinking that the smell you are finding means there's some kind of potty substance on the roof? What you are smelling is a gas from the pipe, and that won't collect on the roof in some black water kind of way. Don't worry about what's coming out of the pipe.
One thing to consider is what are your roof shingles made out of? If they are a tar-based composite, then that water has those bits of tar, that are always breaking down, in it. That's why we have to replace the composite shingles every 15-20 years or so. Most roof water should be used for landscape, not drinking. So it's up to you whether you think the slow breakdown of composite roof shingles is something that would affect your vegetable/food garden.
While it might seem obvious that that water would be bad for food, not all plants uptake all substances. It would take a lab to tell you what's in the water that comes off your roof. As an example, galvanization of shed panels comes off slowly, breaks down in the soil, but plants don't uptake it. The molecules are too big.
You could always put a charcoal filter on the water you've collected from the roof that says it will filter out most toxic substances, then use that water on vegetables.
Mediterranean climate, hugel trenches, fabulous clay soil high in nutrients, self-watering containers with hugel layers, keyhole composting with low hugel raised beds, thick Back to Eden Wood chips mulch (distinguished from Bark chips), using as many native plants as possible....all drought tolerant.