posted 12 years ago
I agree. Another consideration - soil pH. Better to use ash to raise the pH of acidic soil, not necessarily a great idea if your soil is already medium pH, and probably a bad idea if your soil is high pH. The trace nutrients in ash are good for any situation, but you just may need to use the ash very sparingly if you don't have acidic soil. I understand that ash actually reduces the amount of nitrogen produced by composting, however it still might make sense to put it in compost, for example if you have very poor acidic sandy soil like we have, because of the benefits of getting those trace nutrients and increasing the pH.
Certifiable food forest gardener, free gardening advice offered and accepted. Permaculture is the intersection of environmentalsim and agriculture.