This was another great post from the Agrarian Sharing Network on faceplant:
Off the Twitter channel, here's @samknowlton concisely summarizing scientific research powerfully confirming the basic permaculturist axiom that plants don't just grow together, but create entirely new ecosystems. "We don't plant
trees, we plant ecosystems."Toby Hemenway's '
Gaia's Garden' was, of
course, likely the first text to illuminate this phenomenon in terms actionable for, say, urban homesteaders. Toby, by the by, wrote that book when he was a regular teaching and social fixture around Eugene, OR. A truly beautiful soul, sorely missed.
Sam Knowlton's a master at distilling big concepts into bite sized num-nums. This, as such, worth a looksee.
--
Two decades ago, researchers started an experiment that would challenge the prevailing scientific understanding of plant communities.
While modern agriculture treats diversity as inefficient, the Jena Experiment proved the opposite: complexity is the key to resilience.
The setup was simple but groundbreaking.
82 grassland plots, ranging from monocultures to combinations of 60 species, monitored for over 20 years.
What they discovered would expose the fundamental flaws in how we think about agricultural systems.
Plots with 16+ species showed triple the soil
carbon storage, built topsoil 2.7x faster, supported 45% more pollinators, and were 50% more drought resistant than monocultures.
But the numbers only tell half the story.Image
The real breakthrough came from watching these communities evolve.
Species that initially competed fiercely for resources began developing sophisticated sharing networks. The plants weren't just coexisting—they were actively cooperating in ways not previously observed.Image
This wasn't random.
High-diversity plots consistently outperformed monocultures across every metric. After 15 years, they showed 84% less variation in biomass production and recovered from drought twice as fast.
Nature was proving that diversity equals stability.
The findings shatter a core assumption of modern agriculture – that we can predict plant performance based on individual traits.
The most productive combinations weren't those that looked good on paper, they were the ones that had time to adapt to each other.
Below ground, these plant communities were building complex networks.
Soil analysis revealed extensive mycorrhizal connections and unprecedented microbial diversity.
The plants weren't just growing together, they were creating entirely new ecosystems.Image
The implications for cover cropping are far reaching.
The current approach of testing combinations for 1-2 seasons systematically underestimates their potential.
Many of the most successful plant communities in Jena looked unimpressive until year 3 or 4.
The benefits followed a clear timeline:
Year 1-2: Competitive establishment
Year 3-4: Initial cooperation patterns emerge
Year 5-7: Stable resource-sharing networks form
Year 8+: Maximum ecosystem services achieved
This isn't just about soil health. The diverse plots showed:
–180% higher carbon sequestration
–50% lower pest pressure
–70% better nutrient retention
–2.3x higher drought tolerance
All without any external inputs.
The Jena Experiment isn't just research, it's a wake-up call.
We've been simplifying agricultural systems when we
should have been embracing their complexity.
The future of farming isn't in monocultures – it's in managed ecosystems.
https://x.com/nick_routledge/status/1869437087419965943
.png)
11
