posted 14 years ago
Thanks Oaktree! Yes, both volumes are worth the money and worth the time reading, and the plant list is worth noting.
However, after reading these texts, I realized that they were focused on eastern woodland ecotypes that are significantly different than our xeric-to-mesic zone 4 to 5 ecotypes -- in soil, terrain, climate, etc.
Also, being a forester and forestry consultant, I noticed a few misunderstandings about forest ecology. These didn't condemn the general argument, but did raise my amusement level.
And, as far as growing gardens "like" a forest -- in our ecosystem, natural forests (not subject to fire suppression) are mostly constituted by fire-adapted, single canopy stands. These disturbance-based ecosystems rarely resemble their climax communities, and often are constituted by one- or two-species stands with little undergrowth other than fescue grasses -- and literally _no_ vines. So, in this region, we must adapt the paradigm to our own eco-physical realities. Our edible forests will vary markedly from our natural forest structures if we're to be serious at all about production. And, our plant lists will be different than those appropriate to other ecotypes.
However, I've been compiling and reading through a list of sources on the question of what and how much food do we need to grow -- from the food pyramid paradigm (of the USDA, which tends to ignore several key questions but is reference perspective) to S. Fallon's _Nourishing Traditions_ and beyond. I'll post this list as I find time.
BTW, all the books mentioned so far I've read, including Edible Forests and Gaia's Garden, and have appreciated them. My favorite is still Mollison's _Designer Manual_, as it's very specific about the framework and principles. But, these texts all offer valuable contributions.
Thanks for all insight!
Rick Freeman
Interface Forestry, l.l.c. http://interfaceforestry.com
Forest and Stand Inventory and Assessment
Wildfire Fuels Management
Watershed Planning and Stand Planning
Wildlife Habitat Improvement
Recreation and Natural Interpretation Planning
Eco-Wise Residential Planning and Wildland-Urban Interface Forestry
Non-Timber Forest Products
rick@interfaceforestry.com