Swale size in multiple soil types
posted 2 years ago
I've got 13 acres in the Piedmont area of NC. Zone 8b and somewhere around 42 inches of rain per year, elevation 400', south facing slope, 5 acres of trees on the western and southern sides of the land. Toward the front of my property (north side), i have clay right at the surface that i've been covering with horse manure to add humus (while building our house, the builders scalped the ground to the subbase soil). On the south side of the house, i have deep sand with about 4-8" of humus with a lot of broom sedge and blackberries. I'm looking to get a bulldozer out here for some other work that needs to be done, but while it's here, i'm also going to install some swales that i can begin planting a food forest on. The question is--how deep and wide should those swales be, and how far spread apart? I've seen a number of different answers for one particular type of soil, but when i get these swales installed, there are going to be places where i transition from sandy to clay soil.
Also, I've worked out deals with a tree trimming service to start getting wood chips dropped off for free whenever they have a job in the area. Should i fill up my swales with wood chips, or should i mulch the trees which are planted on the backside of the swale? or both? Thanks for the help!
Also, I've worked out deals with a tree trimming service to start getting wood chips dropped off for free whenever they have a job in the area. Should i fill up my swales with wood chips, or should i mulch the trees which are planted on the backside of the swale? or both? Thanks for the help!
Morgan Morris
Posts: 8
posted 2 years ago
Hello Morgan !
I myself spent a lot of time and energy trying to find the optimal swale and interswale size. Eventually, convenience considerations (rather than theoretical 'optimal size') were the ones that determined the final configuration. Luckily my swales turned out just fine and have been working well so far.
My soil is heavy clay, and in rainy periods or during snow melt I have quite a bit of surface runoff on my 0.55 hectare (100x55 metre) plot so I assumed that putting in more - rather than fewer - swales would result in better hydration of the soil, and less surface runoff making it to the bottom 1/3 of the plot, where the house was going to be.
Having said that, I also wanted to have sufficient space in the interval between the swales to be able to put in vegetable gardens and other herbaceous systems.
So I marked out 4 swales at intervals of 15...20 metres. The lowermost swale was marked out about 20 metres above the site of the future house. That took care of the breadth of the interval. But on the day when the man with the excavator showed up, I was still undecided as to the width and depth of the swale itself.
The 'convenience considerations' that I mentioned above were the size of the hoe and the operator's preferred technique (he only brought one hoe with him - I don't recall the size - and it would have meant a half a day's delay if I had decided I needed a larger / differently shaped one). The man dug the swale with the hoe tilted at about 45 degrees. The resulting swale was v-shaped, with a width of about 70 cm at the top, and a depth of about 50 cm. I believe that's a relatively narrow & steep shape, which apparently is suitable for clay soils. If my soil had been of the looser/ sandier type, I may have asked the operator to change his technique and/or hoe so as to obtain a wider / flatter swale. Narrow & steep would not be very stable in sandy soil, I believe - in looser soil I would have kept a depth of up to 50 cm and would have widened the swale to up to 100 cm at the top, with a rather flat bottom.
As for wood chip / other mulch in the swale... I'm sure the mulch would do wonders for the microbiology of the soil in & around the swale. And with a woodchip-filled swale you would probably find it easier to manage the herbaceous vegetation growing inside the swale and the inner slope of the berm. (Mowing the inside of my swales is a real pain in the neck, especially on the side of the berm, where the slope is deeper & steeper.)
However,... I find it very exciting every time I see the swale fill up with water. Whenever that happens, I have standing water for up to a week, during which time the whole feel of the place changes... And this standing water offers you further options - for instance, I intend to divert the (excess) water from my swales into an underground cistern and/or a small seasonal pond.
That's all from me, I hope it helps !
L_
I myself spent a lot of time and energy trying to find the optimal swale and interswale size. Eventually, convenience considerations (rather than theoretical 'optimal size') were the ones that determined the final configuration. Luckily my swales turned out just fine and have been working well so far.
My soil is heavy clay, and in rainy periods or during snow melt I have quite a bit of surface runoff on my 0.55 hectare (100x55 metre) plot so I assumed that putting in more - rather than fewer - swales would result in better hydration of the soil, and less surface runoff making it to the bottom 1/3 of the plot, where the house was going to be.
Having said that, I also wanted to have sufficient space in the interval between the swales to be able to put in vegetable gardens and other herbaceous systems.
So I marked out 4 swales at intervals of 15...20 metres. The lowermost swale was marked out about 20 metres above the site of the future house. That took care of the breadth of the interval. But on the day when the man with the excavator showed up, I was still undecided as to the width and depth of the swale itself.
The 'convenience considerations' that I mentioned above were the size of the hoe and the operator's preferred technique (he only brought one hoe with him - I don't recall the size - and it would have meant a half a day's delay if I had decided I needed a larger / differently shaped one). The man dug the swale with the hoe tilted at about 45 degrees. The resulting swale was v-shaped, with a width of about 70 cm at the top, and a depth of about 50 cm. I believe that's a relatively narrow & steep shape, which apparently is suitable for clay soils. If my soil had been of the looser/ sandier type, I may have asked the operator to change his technique and/or hoe so as to obtain a wider / flatter swale. Narrow & steep would not be very stable in sandy soil, I believe - in looser soil I would have kept a depth of up to 50 cm and would have widened the swale to up to 100 cm at the top, with a rather flat bottom.
As for wood chip / other mulch in the swale... I'm sure the mulch would do wonders for the microbiology of the soil in & around the swale. And with a woodchip-filled swale you would probably find it easier to manage the herbaceous vegetation growing inside the swale and the inner slope of the berm. (Mowing the inside of my swales is a real pain in the neck, especially on the side of the berm, where the slope is deeper & steeper.)
However,... I find it very exciting every time I see the swale fill up with water. Whenever that happens, I have standing water for up to a week, during which time the whole feel of the place changes... And this standing water offers you further options - for instance, I intend to divert the (excess) water from my swales into an underground cistern and/or a small seasonal pond.
That's all from me, I hope it helps !
L_
|
The two armies met. But instead of battle, they decided to eat some pie and contemplate this tiny ad:
Thread Boost feature
https://permies.com/wiki/61482/Thread-Boost-feature
|
