Hey there! Got your email, as a heads-up. I'm hitting the hay now and mowing yet still more tomorrow morning but should be able to get a good, detailed response for you tomorrow.
Long story short, a good scythe is a good scythe, and a bad one is a bad one. Both major styles, properly maintained, tuned, and used, are great--it's just a matter of where emphasis was placed in their respective designs. As you've already noticed, my overall preference is the American, but I own and use scythes from all over.
