First of all I don't know if any of this will resonate with anyone, because I may have a somewhat unique vantage point, as well as a unique attitude, so I'll ask to have this considered as a possible outcome for all these very "non sustainable" ventures, and how they might fit into Permaculture--eventually.
Some of you may have noticed Tesla and Elon Musk and likely there's even an X community of Permaculture people. And an idea is coming to me as I am watching articles on His new super computer with
XAI.
Now I understand that Bill would have us abandon the "car crate" and just dwell on the land, and that idea is very appealing, so I understand the idea of transitioning to electrical transport may seem like an unnecessary detour simply encouraging people to believe the idea that speedy personal transport in and out of misc eco systems/localities is a good thing.
Advances in misc technical apparatus/tools will ultimately be of no use to us and we will simply wander around like innocent children harvesting our food, in perfect harmony with the earth.
Now I like that idea, and 10 years into my practice of Permaculture it is more of a religion with three simple ethics than any other spiritual concepts I have ever tested.
This is a pretty lengthy buildup to present the idea that all of these tremendous advances seemingly moving toward the Jetsons rather than the garden of Eden may actually be a major advance on the road to a truly sustainable future.
Cars are almost driving themselves already, adapting to detours, misc pedestrians, and all the other stupid human tricks people can throw at them. The new Grok AI will be increasing it's intelligence by leaps and bounds. Musk predicts it will encompass all Human knowledge and thought power around 2028--that's right, even your ideas about food forests, dams, etc etc may be included in that knowledge.
Thousands of robots will be walking around doing factory jobs by 2027 (some are already doing productive work in Musk's factory). How long will it be before people really don't have to work at all. Even the dream of installing small dams through the entire length of the Mississippi River to totally slow, spread and soak the worst possible floods could be made feasible if the robots can be taught to understand what is really necessary.
Plant and care for very well thought out food forests and natural forests changing weather patterns lessening the need for wasteful resource consumption with out dated harvesting techniques--drones that daily scan forests and pick only the ripe fruit. Smaller diverse orchards and fields precisely managed by tireless workers(robots) while we paint and sculpt or meditate, and make love.
It is easy to say humans can do all these jobs and robots will just confuse the issue, let us just do our Permaculture in peace. The question I would ask is do you really see humans doing all these things in the next several years?
I mean we are already seeing wonderful exchanges of ideas here on Permies, and much of that is possible by use of AI (primitive as it may be at times). Imagine asking a question and having it answered immediately in a precise and thoughtful way. Even just having a search engine that could understand complex Permaculture concepts and direct us to the posts that deal with the topic. (I haven't used the search engine here recently, too many memories of futile attempts to communicate with the robots here) Whether we think these advances are good or bad they are coming and most of us are still deeply entwined with them (whether we know it or not)
It is somewhat difficult to imagine, but try, a world where everything is available for free and money becomes obsolete.
I'm not suggesting we should sit back on our laurels, waiting for the future, just that these developments are here, and we may have little say about whether they will happen, just suggest that nothing is forbidden in Permaculture and it's more a question of how we use these new tools.
All that is left is giving proper information to our robot overlords, so they have an idea of what is possible (and necessary) for us to continue living a sustainable existence here on this beautiful blue marble. :-)