I give this hatchery 9 out of 10 acorns. They have a wide variety of chicks, started pullets, and other fowl (turkeys, ducks, geese, quail, guineas, etc.). Pricing is reasonable and their shipments have always been on time and accurate.
Sexing of chicks has been very accurate - the counts have been exactly what I ordered. (They usually include an extra chick with the order, and it has always been a rooster in my experience).
One shipment I ordered did not come through due to a predator problem at one of their suppliers (for some rare/specialty chickens). They notified me of the problem and issued a full refund in a timely fashion. This was disappointing but bound to happen from time to time and I thought they handled the situation very well.