Good Day Permies!
I am struggling a bit with the whole Christmas event and specifically that of the Christmas Tree. I will list my dilemma and my thoughts, but what I'm hoping to find is some inspiration / ideas for a better way to do Xmas tree's (especially in the future as this Xmas is rapidly approaching).
1. Buying a tree from a lot. Unless you know where the trees come from and how they were raised it is probably a monocrop that has been covered in chemicals...also I'm cheap and that option is expensive.
2. Fake tree...Can be used every year...made of such horrible garbage that it will fall apart eventually and cannot be recycled.
3. Buy a live tree...High likelihood of dying as being inside will break the tree's dormancy (from what i have read). Either keep it indoors for ~4 days or prepare to keep it the whole winter indoors and plant out in spring...potential option for us but we are space limited.
4. Harvest a tree from the forest. We live in rural Montana with national forest land nearby. We could go harvest a tree for next to free (typically $5) and use that. We could compost the tree when done with it and overall the damage is relatively low. However when we drove past the road to the national forest last weekend there was a solid stream of cars coming down from the forest...all with a 8' "perfect" xmas tree on top. This got me thinking about how extractive this was from the forest and how the average person is probably harvesting a "perfect" tree from an open area and thus doing harm to the forest. These are not trees that need to be removed from the forest...this is the next generation of trees being removed so that they can be a decoration for 3 weeks...Additionally I have run into a moral dilemma of viewing the forest as somewhere that I go to get things (like a store) and then stuff just magically repopulates...This is the exact mindset that leads to mass ecological degradation. Even though we could practive good forestry (remove a gangly tree from the understory that probably won't make it and will eventually turn into forest fire fodder) I still struggle as I don't want to be a part of the concept that the forest is where you go to get stuff. I don't want to be a part of the normalization that makes the poor forestry habits of others seem ok. (I might also be reading way to much into this one

.
5. Craft our own fake tree. I've seen some ideas on here of trees that look great...and it's probably the future for us, but i'm not sure i can get it done in time to get it decorated for this year.
6. Potted plant. We have done this in the past with a Norfolk pine...I can tell you now that we have exactly 0 Norfolk pines in our house (although we have moved multiple times so that might be why...don't recall if they died or got given away when we moved). I have thought about getting the biggest Rosemary that i can find and shaping it into a tree shape...
I will also add that we have a 5 year old daughter who aboslutely loves Christmas and the decorating... She has already stated that whatever we do has to look like a real tree with the smell and everything...
So...Help me out Permies. Have I gone off the rails on harvesting a tree from the forest (assuming I use good forestry practices)? Anyone have any other thoughts / ideas / inspiration?
Thanks,
Colter