posted 1 year ago
I suspect it depends on where you are and how does soil build up naturally where you live.
For example, a lot of places, the soil builds by leaves and plant matter falling then decomposing. Fruits, foods, etc, would pass through an animal before adding to the mulch. If you live in a place where this happens fairly quickly, without smells, and without scavengers like rats, birds, and more vicious creatures, then go for it.
But like nature, there are loads of different ways we can build soil. Where I live it's either too dry or too cold for the leaf litter to compost on top of the soil, so it either crumbles into a dust during the summer, or it has to wait a year and a half for the next layer of leaves to trap in the moisture before it starts decomposing. We also have a lot of rats and other animals that love scavenging off human food scraps, so we pre-compost or trench compost (nature has to dig as part of soil building in some places too - like animals burying food then forgetting about it) because it's easier to prevent rats than to get rid of them.
Then there are half-way methods like layering the scraps under mulch.
If you have any disease, (or potential like tomatoes or potatoes), pests, or things you don't want to seed, then heat composting is a good idea.
Lots of choices. Try as many as you can and see which work for you.